*** Long Update ***
So the PI followed her and the guy guy around Friday night. They had dinner and went home. Nothing happened. I met him and we chatted for a bit when they got home.
Saturday, they did the race with my buddy (who I trust) and we all went out that night.
His flight was early Sunday morning so we stayed up and then she drove him to the airport. According to the recorder in her car, they chatted about the race and nothing much happened until the last few minutes before he got out at the airport. More about this later.
Sunday, I got up and let her sleep until about 10am when I couldn't stand it any longer and woke her.
I first told her about how horrible of a week I've had and then I told her it was because she had been lying to me about many things and that now she needed to tell me to the truth. She was silent a long time and I asked if she was trying to come up with a good story. She then answered my questions. When she lied, I told her it was a lie. I never told her how I knew, but she's not stupid.
To sum up:
She says the only physical contact was a long kiss and hug while dropping him at the airport. Based on what I know, this seems true.
She admitted to lying to me about all the things that I knew, but still refuses to apologize for the lying. This still mystifies me. I think it's because in her mind she lied to me for my sake. Yea, whatever. On the plus side at least she's not just telling me what I need to hear.
She keeps saying that it's just a friendship like with any other friend. I of course ask if she buys other friends secret gifts or deletes messages to them. She says no and drops it for a time.
She admits that she doesn't know how things would be different if this guy were close. He's across the country. I told her that I think she would have been having a full blown affair.
She admits that the panties thing was incredibly stupid. I agreed.
She admits that she would have been fine keeping things as the were indefinitely. I told her that I saw an escalation and I believe that things would continue to escalate.
She told me that she would drop contact with this guy if asked. I told her that it was her choice but that reconciliation would be incredibly difficult with him in the picture even as a "friend."
She told me how it's unfair to lose this friend. I told her that was her fault because of her actions.
So right now, she's sad and withdrawn. She says she wants to save the marriage, but I feel she's really just sad at the prospect of loosing him. We have our rings on and I am fully committed to the 180.
I'm trying to follow the advice in the Just Friends book and not make any sweeping decisions/ultimatums right now, but I have told her that I need several things.
1. A full and heartfelt apology for the lying and deceit over the last few months.
2. She needs to fully realize that her relationship was not "just friends"
3. I need her to be honest.
There will probably be more. We've talked about counseling. She said she would go if she had to, but didn't want to. I think it's a good idea to try.