Never make an ultimatum you won’t back up.
Seriously. What Marz said. Saying something and not doing/meaning it doesn't help you. Better to say nothing.
I'd say struggling with the decision is a gross understatement of what I am doing. I really don't understand what I am doing. It doesn't make any sense even to me. I could not live with the constant reminder that he is still around her.
So set me straight if I'm off-base: you're narrowed down, basically, to choosing between two basic options for yourself. Having health insurance and more money/house but not really getting out of a situation that, by your own admission, you "could not live with" vs. 180 and heading toward D, with the understanding that if things don't turn around with WW (she doesn't get a different job or do whatever else you need), then you will follow through with D. Is that right?
~
When people with experience try to explain the 180 to new BS's, it's always so time-consuming and there is always so much nuance to it...it's really tricky because a new BS just cannot wrap their heads around the fact that taking these actions help them so much and truly turn the tables. I think most BS truly fear that they will "push" their WS's away by doing the 180 and will ruin their chances at salvaging their marriage.
Always with the caveat that the 180 is not disingenuous, it's not lying, it's not a way to trick your spouse into thinking you're leaving them when you secretly never would...it really is about you getting out of infidelity.
But a very, very common side-effect of *really* doing the 180 is that the WS completely changes their tune.
That's not a guarantee, and again, I CAN'T stress enough that if you go into it with the mentality that you're tricking your WW back to "loving" you or something, you will crash and burn.
I also can't stress enough that if you do the 180 and *do* see the common side-effect of your WS saying "Wait! Hold on! I'll do anything to fix this!", that still doesn't mean that things are hunky-dory and you can ride off into the sunset. There would still be so much work to do, and it still might not work out in the end.
I told her that tonight and it devolved into a huge argument
So how are these conversations and arguments working out for you?
Imagine an alternate history where, instead of constant discussion and arguing over the past, say, 48 hours, you had just stopped talking to your wife altogether except for business stuff. If you had stopped engaging, stopped pushing to talk, stopped sharing meals with her, stopped watching TV with her, etc. Just totally going a different way.
What would have happened? Would she seek you out, ask why you're acting different?
If she did that, what if you had said something like "it's become clear to me that you cannot or will not do the one thing I truly need in order to try to move forward from this point with you. And as much as I don't like it and as much as it breaks my heart, I'm realizing I have to go in another direction, because I cannot exist in this marriage with a partner who won't work with me on this very necessary requirement for a reconciliation. I have no choice but to work toward divorce whether I like it or not. If something changes in what you're doing, I may consider stopping the process, but I may not--it may be too late by then. Either way, I'm moving in this direction, and I intend to see it through based on everything in front of me now."
What would have happened then? Would she have tried to engage you? To fight with you? Make you feel bad? Yell at you? Etc.??
What if, if she did do or say any of that, you simply said "I can see you're upset, but I don't have any choice. You're free to do anything you want now, and I won't stop you. I'm going to my room now." And then went to your room and played candy crush on your phone? Maybe start looking at those divorce papers?
What would happen then? Would she keep trying to engage? Ask questions? Fight? Try to argue? Try to discuss?
If she did, what if you said "I don't have anything to talk about unless it's about kids or finances. I'm not angry and I'm not trying to fight, but these conversations are over for me." Or even a simple "I don't want to talk about that right now," or "We can talk about that another time."
~
This is what the 180 looks like in practice.
[This message edited by Okokok at 9:21 AM, April 26th (Sunday)]