I think you need to reset your expectations in this regard.
Your attorney is not your counselor, IC or friend. They are there to represent your business interests in the dissolution of your marriage. Certainly they can do so with compassion and empathy, but that is not their primary responsibility.
There are other nuances that someone giving a consult is not going to get into, such as dissipation of marital assets (i.e. him spending money on the affair) that may or may not be subject to division between the parties.
A consult is just that: a consultation. A job interview, so to speak. You're interviewing attorneys. OK, so this one wasn't a good fit. Find someone else. Interview a couple of someone elses. Make a list of questions to ask, such as how things like dissipation of marital assets are handled (if that is germane to your case).
Now, how to find a good attorney. I don't rely on word of mouth. Most large metropolitan areas have a "Best of the Best" series where they list the best doctors, dentists . . . and attorneys. I'd start there.
First, you want someone who specializes in family law. You don't want someone who is handling bankruptcies, DUIs and such to take on your divorce. You want a specialist.
Secondly, I would think you would also want to look for a firm that has all levels of attorneys from the professional pit bulls and sharks in heels to more junior associates and paralegals. Why is this important? You don't want your attorney who is charging you $250 an hour to be making your copies. By having a larger firm, your costs can actually be reduced. The paralegal or admin does the grunt work, the junior associate drafts the paperwork and the senior associate reviews it. You may not even need a senior associate, but that is something that you and the attorney you hire would need to discuss.
Child support is normally a formula based on the parties earnings and, in some states, parenting time.
Spousal support is usually "rehabilitative support" designed to get a former SAHP into the working world.
Infidelity may or may not be a factor in the division of assets and debt.
Debt may or may not be split evenly. There may be debt that belongs solely to one individual (i.e. student loans, where the other party doesn't really benefit from that education investment). It depends on the laws of your state.
As you can see, a consultation is not going to get into the weeds with this. They are merely giving you an overview of how they would take your case, what you might reasonably expect in broad, BROAD terms and how they work as an attorney and as a firm. That's ALL you really get out of a consult.
So, go find some additional attorneys to interview. View this as a business transaction. Certainly you want and deserve basic kindness and empathy, but your attorney is not your counselor.
Cat