Chiming in because I have a WH who has memory issues due to some heavy impact accidents he was dealt when serving. The bitter thing is, being a narc and expert manipulator, due to his poor memory, he believes the lies, it’s a nightmare no therapist can unravel and if there is one I have yet to meet them.
Here is my concerns about this.
= LTAP still in free contact. You think it’s been out of the blue but honestly if he is treating you this poorly over a piece of metal can you honestly say there was a NC gap?
= If LTAP is aware of WH memory issues she could be fishing for $. This bracelet might have been tin, she knows her crap was tossed (assuming you let her know at one time or told him and he told her??) so now she is in need of $ and will say something like it was a gold bracelet with diamonds and if he won’t return it then he has to buy her a replacement... probably do this for a few “treasures” so she can sell it for $.
= Or this is their way to meet. She thinks he kept her “treasures” (using that description puts emphasis on it’s extreme importance to guilt trip WH) so him handing them back (bet my money she would refuse postage because they’re “treasures” and could be lost) allows them to meet/hook up.
= the more she insists it’s high value the more he sees you as the villain for tossing it.
= due to the pressures and fears around the pandemic, reconnecting with past APs seem to be the flavour of the year on pro-adultery forums. So many write about wanting to check in, see how they are etc etc, this bracelet is such a weak excuse I can help speculate this is her trying to fire things up again.
To defuse you need to devalue the bracelet and refocus your WH. You need to ask WH why this is important, May as well have the hard talks if you’re looking towards door option D. You could ask WH to describe this “treasure”, say you will check to see if it’s around, when he describes something say “oh, no, that was never the bracelet, her bracelet was [describe something cheap/ugly], she is either lying to get $ from you or must have given that bracelet WH describe to one of her other men she was screwing around with, she never gave you that one only a [cheap/ugly nothing] one, but I’ll see if that [cheap/ugly trashy] one is here.” Devalue this bracelet, highlight it’s unimportance, because the more he cannot remember and the more she insists this is some super valued bracelet he is lost.
IDK so much more than just a bracelet here, there is smoke and I don’t think it’s coming from this stuff she suddenly wants back.
They can make as many promises as they want, but if they don't put action behind it, it doesn't mean anything.
I edit because I'm fluent in typo & autocorrect hates me.