Desert,
I work with lawyers on a regular basis. They won’t offer you coffee without warning that it might burn your mouth. It’s in their training – they know that despite common sense, tradition and high odds then they can seldom – if ever – guarantee a result and don’t want to give any form of false hope or open themselves up to a malpractice suite.
That’s why attorneys NEVER recommend you expose an affair, despite us old dogs with years of experience in dealing with infidelity KNOWING it’s the absolute best tool to end infidelity. An attorney isn’t interested in ending the affair, he isn’t vested in saving the marriage, he isn’t focusing on what’s best for your marriage. He is focused on HIS job and HIS task: Making sure you don’t do anything that might weaken your legal stance based on how things might progress. Frankly the attorneys motto should be “do no harm” because that is more-or-less what they focus on.
Now – To be fair: I don’t see telling HR about the affair as exposure per se. I see it as an attempt to create conditions that are conductive to YOU being able to focus on reconciliation.
So… What is the attorney thinking: If Mr. and Mrs. Desert expose to HR Mrs. Desert MIGHT be fired. If that happens and the marriage doesn’t work, then Mr. D (the guy who made the appointment and is the prime-customer) might have to pay higher support due to Mrs. D not having a job. Mr. Deserts position will be worse. The attorney will have failed.
I get it when you say you don’t want to tell your wife to leave the job. If you reconcile you want to be a husband and not a warden. I see posts here from spouses here that are constantly monitoring their “reconciled” significant other mileage, bank-account, phone… for years and years. Yes – the days of blind trust are over, but one of the goals of R has to be that some form of accountable trust is created.
We could also create the conditions where your wife leaves her job. We could also talk to HR and OM gets a warning or is fired. We could also leave things like they are and do nothing. Fact is that IF your wife wants to cheat with OM she can. She can get a new job and still see him at lunch. He could get a warning and STILL meet her at the Venus Motel at lunch. Or it could all be over… Your wife could be 100% honest in wanting this over…
Now… Imagine your wife was recovering from alcoholism. She’s just out from 6 weeks of rehab. Shes doing all the right stuff; attending AA, working the steps, changing her patterns, making amends… But… she insists on keeping her job at the high-end liquor store where they sell bespoke whiskey, gin and vodka. High-end stuff and that particular store is the absolute top of her career. She wants to work there because she could make management.
So… the job is in marketing or sales. Really no need for her to drink and theoretically she could do the job as a total teetotaler.
For all you know she is sober. But the simple fact she’s surrounded by booze, has access to samples, has to give samples, has to visit bars and clubs to sell… worries you… Every time she comes home she pretends not to notice you sniff when you kiss her hi. She comes home smelling of gin that got spilt on her blouse and you freak out. On a regular basis you go and search her old storage places where she used to hide a bottle – the laundry basket, behind the flour in the kitchen…
Think you are ideal-husband material? Think living in constant distrust is going to enable you to offer accountable trust?
Even if she is totally honest and completely intent on being sober… YOUR worries will prevent you from reconciling.
And then… One day after an argument… Or one day of weakness… she reaches for OM… sorry – that bottle… And since it’s so close and so accessible… It just happens.
To stick to the alcoholism comparison: Families of alcoholics are told to remove all booze from the home and help the recovering alcoholic by not having booze accessible. So YOU too stop having a beer when you come home and drink soda-water with that T-bone steak. It wont prevent the alcoholic from having a drink if he really wants to. But it does mean he has to get to the store and make the purchase. It takes time and that time is when the alcoholic can change his mind.
You are allowing your wife to work close to her drug. She can be totally committed for 1000 hours but it only takes 10 seconds of nookie to wreck that.
One thing Desert: Does your wife think nobody at the office knows of the affair?