I posted earlier that human behavior is predictable. It really is, and even more so when people feel insulted or threatened or rejected. All things I guess you are probably feeling right now.
I want to make some suggestions:
You don’t have to hate her.
You can’t win divorce. There isn’t a score, and nobody gets a trophy at the end.
I have an attorney friend that once told me that as a competent divorce-attorney he can right away calculate a likely settlement irrespective of how confrontational or aggressive the divorcing couple are. He told me that demands like full custody, all the assets, exuberant spousal support, all the cutlery and both the cats… normally all they do is add legal cost and prolong the process. He told me the difference from his original estimate to the final settlement is usually within 5%.
That corroborates with a 60 Minute segment about the cost of divorce some years ago. An attorney told how a coupe had run up legal bills in the thousands to argue over an old, 300 bucks lawn-mower. Apparently, it had “sentimental value” for both… The legal costs would have allowed both parties to have gotten several new mowers.
Falc – right now the BEST advice I can offer you is to detach and turn this into a non-personal, non-confrontational but firm business transaction. I’m not telling you to lean over backwards or to be accommodating on all requests, but I am strongly suggesting you don’t be combative simply to be combative.
Take control. Not by talking to her, but by getting to your attorney ASAP and organizing a fair divorce. If you are in control you can manipulate slightly to your advantage. For example: Since I guess you plan on keeping the home you can present a realistic market-price in the lower-end, thereby minimizing a possible gap between mortgage and market-value. Just for argument’s sake: Let’s say the house real market value is 100 and the loan stands at 80 = 20 in assets and she is entitled to 10 in the total debt/asset ratios. If you could convincingly (as in an outside relator might agree with your logic) that due to the leaking roof, broken gutters and need to fix the driveway the REAL market-value is 90 then you have just saved yourself 90 – 80 = 10 / 2 = 5.
You can offer her car at full KBB value rather than depreciated private-sale, lowered because the tires are bald, and the doors dented.
Get it? You can massage numbers slightly SLIGHTLY in your favor.
But be realistic and be fair.
By being the initiator, you gain this control. You can offer, rather than negotiate what is offered. You can start whatever argument (and despite all attempts of being cordial divorce will always be an argument) from YOUR grounds rather than whatever she, her dad or her attorney offer.
That ticket? A non-issue. To me her asking what she can do to that ticket is the same as you ask if you can finish her half of the yoghurt that was in the fridge the day she left.
Focus on detachment and finalizing the divorce.
Honestly Falc – that is what will most likely get you what you need (emotional freedom from her) AND is possibly your best shot at getting what you (still) want (a chance to reconcile). I’m 100% certain you can get the former, but really doubt the second will ever take place.