***Posting as a member***
I think the one thing that happens in cases of both genders is that we see the WS state in desperation, " I will do anything if you agree to stay with me."
You see the problem with this is that the BS wants to believe so badly that they take it at face value. They fully expect that anything means anything. If that is wild crazy hanging from the chandeliers sex then so be it. If it is telling you unprompted how beautiful you are every so often then so be it. Let's be honest most WS aren't playing with a full emotional deck, with healthy coping skills in the first place. A lot are fresh off a selfish place where they learned that manipulation works for them. It might be genuine, but it is a statement made of fear. Fear of suffering the consequences of their choices.
Where this falls apart is where the WS words don't match their actions. Suddenly refusals happen. So the BS is left with the understanding that they were lied to, yet again. Any trust that existed or was built is now gone.
We always say that words are worthless and if they don't match actions they are untrue. That is why. The value of truth is greatly diminished in the wayward mind. This character deficit doesn't go away overnight.
That is the thing that really gets at a lot of BS. Anything suddenly becomes except x, y or z. Confusing as all get out. Sex is no exception. While this bothers a lot of BS the thing is that these can be the WS learning boundaries. Boundaries are needed in R. BS get to have them too, but to a BS we likely had them all along. These do change over time. Maybe today x,y, and z are outside of their boundaries. Tomorrow? Well I think anything is fair game when negotiating marriage 2.0.
In my scenario I did not have to compete with anything special in the physical sense. It was pathetic to the point of being a basis for a very adult comedy. I made my peace with it a lot faster than anything else. The fact that she didn't or couldn't talk to me about how she was feeling left me feeling used, and taken for granted. Part of that was I seemed to be a domestic resource and a wallet. No loving actions at all that included "duty" sex. Which you should know is worse than none at all for most guys. We feel the insincerity and yes it does hurt in ways that many BWs can't relate to.
Going back to DF earlier post (Hi DF) I have to agree with her sentiment.
We choose our partner as a whole. We don't get to pick what we like and don't about them. They are a package deal. Full disclosure, my W is not the best sex I ever had. Probably not even close to the top spot. She is downright prudish at times. She had/has other qualities that I value. She was kind to animals and small children. She is organized (I am not). She wants the same things I want out of life now, tomorrow and in old age. She is a terrific mother. She is good with money. She is a solid worker who earns good money at what she does. She is the not sex goddess, but as I get older that matters much less to me. It is about building a life with someone. Not one aspect of our lives together is not influenced by other parts too. If we struggle in one area it is in the bedroom. We discuss that more than anything lately.
I will say that we tend to focus on the problems and whatever need is not being met the most. If all of my other needs are met except sex then that becomes 90% of my focus. If I am hungry food is my priority. I've had a dead bedroom before. It hurt emotionally beyond anything I can put into words. Well beyond actually. It was demoralizing and hurtful to be continually turned down. I tried to be intimate in other ways, but honestly my heart was not in them and it showed. I was too hurt to communicate effectively with my W. Hurt clouds your feelings in ways that nothing else can. Further it taught me that any vulnerability would lead to more pain. Any physical intimacy short of sex also carried the sting of possible rejection. I mean I can cuddle my dog. I can hug my children. The only person I can have a sexual relationship is my wife if I want to live a life of integrity that is in line with my values. If that isn't present and/or that is not fulfilling to me then that becomes 90% of my issues in my M. We communicate about it now though. She tries to meet me half way.
My W tried to argue with me that it was not be all end all of our relationship too. I had to have a lot of conversations from a male perspective before she got it. It was the very part she damaged with her physical part of her A (despite that being comically pathetic) and it needed to be healed if we were to be successful long term. For some that might mean more frequency. It might mean exploring new things together (which speaks to the pain that BH feel when certain acts are denied to them, but given to an AP). It might just mean having sex with the lights on while looking each other in the eyes (Intimacy).
There needs to be very open and unfiltered conversations to facilitate any healing activity. You can ask and they can comply, but that leads to resentment. Sometimes that is a milestone you have to reach for awhile, but it can't be stuck there. All needs should be discussed and explained why it is important. That is just rebuilding a new M where both of your needs are met. I get to define my needs in my M. Any of you get the same right. You might not get 100%, but again that isn't healthy either. The only exceptions for my W and I are that emotional and physical intimacy of a certain level are only met by each other.
Most H have trouble extending emotional vulnerability. It is not comfortable and OMG it is beyond terrifying at times. Putting yourself into a vulnerable place and then being rejected, in any way, makes it less likely they will do that again any time soon. Nobody likes to take actions that cause them pain. No one.
Both men and women are fragile, but in different ways. When we generalize and/or use our own views as a proxy for understanding someone else's need in Limbo/R/D. . .well that is where advice conducive to healing stops.