aas, of course you're sad. That your family life had to come to this, that you can no longer be with your boys 100% of the time in your shared family home is very sad. But given the level of cruelty, spite, arrogance and craziness of your stbx who forced you and your boys to be in this situation in the first place my outsiders opinion is that your barrister is right and given what could have happened, you have just won BIG.
It seems that on virtually every issue that she forcefully exerted her arrogance and cruelty over your contact with the boys this past year, she's now lost.
She blackmailed you into signing an agreement that you wouldn't keep the boys on the Sunday nights of your weekend with them - even going so far as withholding them until you did. That agreement is now not worth the paper it's written on. You have your Sunday nights. By law.
In an extremely cruel and demented move she listed Gru as the boys 'next of kin' - she can never do that again. She must list you in your rightful place as next of kin to the boys - by law.
She didn't want you attending the boys after school activities on her time, even threatening police action to keep you away. You are now fully entitled to attend 'any and all' after school activities - by law.
She wanted to dictate how much holiday time you could have the boys for. You have won equal time. That you've had to concede a little of that due to your own holiday entitlement is a shame, but you still won equal time in principal.
It's a shame that you lost your Wednesday nights, but you do have alternate Tuesdays and your eow Sunday nights to make up for it. That in itself is another win.
I agree with you about the big win being the primary caregiver roles being equal and that she must consult with you on the non day to day decisions regarding the boys. I'm sure that one must have cut her to the bone and if any of these rulings will have her kicking back against, I predict it will be that one. But you have it in writing now, on a legal document. I just hope she can abide by it and not make you have to fight through the courts again. Surely at some point she has to understand that she cannot do just as she pleases. I hope she comes to that understanding sooner rather than later.
Regarding the summer holidays dates, it's simply ludicrous for her to expect you to commit to specific weeks for the next twelve years. It's hard enough booking holidays from work on a year to year basis. No reasonable person is even going to take a demand like that seriously - and frankly it's one of her more laughable requests. I'm glad that you are already determined to hold your ground on it.
Finally I would like to say something about the Christmas schedule aas. You know, if I were given the choice of those two options, I would rather have the schedule you have than the one she has and I do mean that seriously. If I were her, I would spend my Christmas morning counting down the hours until you came to take the boys. I'd feel that I was on a time limit and I would feel that most strongly. Presents must be opened and played with, and put away, and Christmas dinner must be all done and dusted by 3pm.
You on the other hand, (hopefully) get children super excited and happy knowing that they have yet another Christmas day coming at your house. No doubt she will force them to leave their new toys behind - afterall - I doubt she'll ever put the boys first, but they have an evening of anticipation ahead, maybe an early present for the evening, and then an unhurried Christmas Day on Boxing Day. Your Christmas time with the boys will all be to come, with time to enjoy it, rather than rushed and on a schedule. So although of course it would be ideal to get the boys for the whole day Christmas every other year, the fact is she never gets them for the 'whole day' anyway. I honestly would rather your schedule.
OK, I have to go, but I just had to come and comment aas because after following you from the beginning, I am thrilled that your fight paid off. Yes, it cost a ridiculous amount of money and a lot of heartache along the way, but you won, and you won big in the end. I hope today goes equally well.