DoneGone
As your hide might have experienced then I‘m sort of the resident hard-ass here on SI.
So the following might come as a surprise…
IMHO it’s best when we BS have a sense of direction.
It’s best when we can take aim at some distant object and tell stakeholders that that’s where we are going.
To me that destination shouldn’t necessarily be divorce or reconciliation. It should be OUT OF INFIDELITY.
Deciding on R or D right away and committing to it is like defining whether you plan to take a car, plane, boat or bike for a destination you haven’t really realized where is. All you really know post-d-day is that you want out of infidelity…
Generally the path out of infidelity tends to be true reconciliation OR true divorce.
If our WS offers reconciliation and it’s based on commitment and ENOUGH initial remorse then and only then do we have a choice. We the BS can choose to reconcile or we can choose divorce.
[By ENOUGH remorse I’m referring to my thoughts that a WS isn’t really capable of showing true remorse until and unless they fully get the scope of the damage they caused, and that doesn’t happen until well into reconciliation IMHO.]
But most of the times the WS doesn’t offer what’s required to reconcile. They might say they want the marriage but with conditions, they might hide the affair, keep secrets… All sort of things that make R impossible. Then our ONLY option to our destination – OUT OF INFIDELITY – is divorce. That’s what your wife is offering right now. She’s offering R but without the necessary foundation to build R on.
Divorce isn’t the same as TRUE divorce. The Big D isn’t an alternative marriage. It’s the termination of a relationship. You two separate all financials and as much emotional as possible. You do your co-parenting and since your kids are relatively old then that’s rather limited. Do a “true” divorce and within 18 months you won’t be seeing your wife or contacting her much at all. Way too often people “divorce” but still live unnecessarily intertwined lives.
Now…
Your WW had an affair. That’s the only thing that matters right now.
Your anger is a total non-issue AS LONG as you don’t use the anger to control your wife, abuse her or dominate her. I sense that none of that applies to you.
This is where it gets confusing though…
You say that NO MATTER WHAT you will divorce your wife.
Then you say you wish it didn’t have to be that way.
Then you act in a way that doesn’t indicate a will to divorce…
You two have 25+ years history. Family, kids, joint friends… D is a big decision.
But why do you want to divorce?
Do you feel you have to? Some perceived pressure or expectance on your behalf?
Do you fear you won’t ever forgive?
Or… Do you WANT TO divorce?
Look – If the infidelity is a total 100% deal breaker then divorce. Go ahead. That’s totally within your rights or whatever you want to call it.
IF however you have doubts… well… there is no shame in changing modes of transport mid-way to your destination, nor is there any wrong in altering path as long as you are heading in the direction of your goal.
I for one think your MC is a waste of time.
I think an MC that interviews your WW for several sessions and then pulls you in for a joint session… There is no way that MC can be impartial. If you really have the money to waste on that sort of BS then please donate it to SI.
But…
You need the truth.
There are respected and major contributors here on SI that have reconciled marriages from numerous affairs. IF the truth is that your wife’s affair with this man was more extensive than she admits then YOU CAN RECONCILE if you want to.
There are respected and major contributors here that have divorced for less than what your WW has already fessed up to.
It’s TOTALLY YOUR CALL.
But… Working towards D while working at R is about as senseless as working towards R when working towards D…
IF you are determined to divorce then divorce. Stop the MC, stop the messaging, stop finding out more. The phone, the computer… totally irrelevant.
If you have your doubts about divorce then stop MC. Make it so very very clear to your wife that you need the truth for there to be ANY CHANCE of reconciliation. I have addressed this before: Create a situation where she tells you the truth without KNOWING it automatically leads to divorce. A situation where she realizes her only option is the truth.
This is possibly the ONLY use I can see in the MC. If your WW answers a list of questions you put forth regarding the truth and the MC acts as an intermediary. The MC could possibly read the answers to you that your WW gave her previously.
But DoneGone – IF you are determined to divorce then go ahead and divorce. Don’t prolong this for either of you. Tell your wife, file… get the ball rolling.