I'm so sorry that you are here because I know the pain you are going through. But that is why this is such a great place -- many others understand what you are going through and will come alongside to offer you insight as to what is happening and how to avoid the mistakes we made. One thing you need to understand is that the patterns of a cheater are predictable. With the thousands upon thousands of post here, the stories all end up with common threads. Your story so far, while absolutely awful, already is similar in some key areas to many others.
For a cheater, the affair is like a drug addiction -- it is a high and they will do almost anything to get another hit. Words and promises are empty. Actions matter. You're beginning to see exactly how this plays out. Each time you confront your wife with the evidence, she then knows how to craft a story that minimizes the real truth of the matter and she learns how to better evade detection. The affair only goes deeper undercover.
However, she continues personal contact with him.
This is a critical point for both you and your wife.
For your wife, real change starts with absolutely no contact with the other man. Ever again. No personal contact AND no business contact. None of this "we are just friends" or "it is only for business" or "he just gave me a ride". It is too late for either of those to ever be an option again (not to mention they are all lies anyway). As long as she has any connection with him, she is open to pursuing another hit/high.
For you, it is important to come to the point where you won't accept a marriage with another man in it. You have core needs to be loved and respected, but, in this case, you are accepting the ultimate lack of it. For your own health and sanity, this needs to be a non-negotiable.
That being said, there are 4 non-negotiables for you to even consider the possibility that the marriage might be able to be saved.
1. No Contact (NC). She writes a letter/email that you see and approve ahead of time to the OM (other man). It indicates that she has made a huge mistake, that she needs to fix the marriage/family that she damaged and that there will be NC going forward. Forever. And then she actually abides by that.
2. Transparency. You get access to everything -- email, social media, her phone, her location, etc. No hidden accounts. No apps that hide communication.
3. Honesty. She tells the truth about everything. You get to ask any question you want and she answers honestly. Not just once and not just now, but always going forward.
4. IC (individual counseling). Having an affair shows that there is a character gap deep inside of your wife. She needs to own that, find it and fix it. IC is a tool that she can use (as long as she has the self-motivation to do the hard work) in order to sort herself out and to become a safe partner for you.
If she refuses, she isn't a safe partner and the disrespect is going to slowly suck the life out of you.
What really complicated things is we have a beautiful16 month old and I can’t imagine a life without seeing her everyday.
That absolutely makes this so much more painful. However, it doesn't change the fundamental focus. Children catch their character from their parents and you only control your part of that equation. Your child will either learn that it is OK to be treated with a lack of love/respect or that it is never OK to accept this.
I know this doesn't make the situation any easier, but putting in the effort to do what is right for you sets you up to be a healthy, attentive parent that your child will need regardless of what happens to the marriage.
If you did the math, yes the affair started a few months after my daughter was conceived and continued after her birth.
As far as you know right now. Get a paternity test done. It will either solidify that what you believe is true or it will help you see and deal with an even bigger reason why your wife refuses to end her affair.
To rebuild trust, we have GPS sharing apps...I used the app to see she was at a grocery store over lunch. I drove there...My assumption is she was with her AP and that it’s still going on.
Your wife is showing you over and over again that she can't be trusted, that she will take advantage of you and that she will disrespect you. While that is incredibly painful, the most important thing you can do right now is to take the steps needed to understand the situation you are caught in and why you are tolerating the untolerable. Many others here (myself included) ended up in the same position and had to take the same steps. I'd recommend a starting point of reading through The Healing Library (http://www.survivinginfidelity.com/faq.asp), especially the FAQ for Betrayed Spouses, and picking up a copy of "No More Mr. Nice Guy" (either at a book store or a PDF copy online). These things should help you gather your strength and begin taking steps that will help the situation resolve itself one way or another.
[This message edited by Crushed7 at 11:38 AM, November 24th (Friday)]