In fact i think my WW is happier than she's ever been.
Questions for Redhorse. Do you feel the same ? People who think they are going to die and make a full recovery often have a zest for life they did not have before. M have a similar dynamic. Was D ever on the table ? What have you two done to heal the M ?
Other than trying to talk to her about it, what else have you tried ? Has she done any IC ? Especially one with experience in sexual trauma? If I had to guess that is a lot of your issue right there.
Have you guys done any MC ? Read any books ?
Can you write her a letter explaining this in great detail so that she can read the entire thought without getting defensive or arguing with you?
I get the impression that you resent your W over this. Resentments don't go away the grow and fester until they can't be ignored. Co-dependcy makes it worse (not saying you, just informational)
One thing that I think that the other gender half of the equation misses is that while "obligation sex" is still sex, Is not the kind of sex that helps you feel close to your W. It does not provide a vulnerable place to feel love from your spouse. It relegates it to another item on a task list like doing laundry or mowing the lawn. The perfunctory release is not the reason why this bothers him. If it were he can meet that need without another person. KWIM ? He isn't looking at this as just a means to an end to meet his physical needs. He wants to feel close to his wife and he wants to know that she wants that too. That is the part he feels is lacking. He feels that he is due some effort in this space just as he has worked to put effort into areas of the M even though they likely were not comfortable for him. He feels he is not worth the effort as his wife won't go outside of her comfort zone despite it proven that she can.
You want to know that your W is into you, in that way. All obligation sex does is reinforce the belief that she is not. You know she has the ability to, but she doesn't feel that you are worth the same level of effort as her AP was. It is hard not to feel less than important to your W. You want to sex is met with a sigh and an a "OK, let's get it over with." That kills a husbands self esteem if that is all that is offered in the bedroom. A's make it so much worse.
We have to watch WS actions because we can't take their words at face value anymore. Well this action is telling Redhorse that his W is happy with the status quo and she isn't willing to do any work here. His sexual confidence was destroyed by the A and he desperately wants that back.
I think IC would be very good for you too Redhorse. I am afraid you can't find the words, courage, strength, whatever to address this is serious way with your W. IC can help you with that.
On another topic. Being the one to initiate all of the time gets old really fast. It creates doubts. Most men's identity is tied to masculinity which includes sexual prowess. Being declined even once in awhile is soul crushing. It becomes easier to avoid sex altogether versus being the one that always that gets rejected or gets pity sex. Obligation sex can be replaced with pity sex. Rejection hurts. Sexless M are created this way.
This type of rejection hurts just as bad as emotional rejection or refusing to pay attention to your spouse does. Most men view their relationship through the lens of the physical relationship.
Viewing it through that lens it looks like redhorse sees a M that she puts with for other reasons than love, attraction or desire. It hurts to think on that, but he can't ignore it any longer.
Redhorse. The sex issues your W has are her problem. You can only ask her to work on them, but my guess is she has some issues there that only a professional would be able to help her with. The fact that she refuses to address this issue despite you asking her to is either her misunderstanding how important this is to you, her refusing to do so because she has not fixed her selfish brokeness that caused the A in the first place or sadly she choose you because of your shared history after looking for a better option and found out that the grass over there is no greener that it is on her side of the fence.
She gets her life back. Of course she is going to be happy. Truth be told she got it back in exactly the same way it was before with added baggage. She needs to put more effort in your M in ways that help you find your happiness too. I fear in both the A and in your M your W feels that sex is the price admission to have the relationship. She doesn't do it because she wants to. She'd be happy with none at all. She needs both medical and psychological approaches to address this issue.
Apart from not cheating anymore, what else has she really done to build a new M?