This thread is fast reaching the 50-page limit, so I want to get a few pointers in:
I think there hasn’t been a +10-hour gap between your posts. Pace yourself. Get some rest. This problem won’t fix itself, it won’t go away, and it will possibly be the dominant factor in your life for anything from 6-18 months. This is too serious to rush. Your decisions will impact you and your family for years to come. Take the advice some have offered and exercise, spend time with your girls, eat… Be physically and/or mentally capable of dealing with the issues.
Deal with reality – not fiction or fantasy.
IMHO you probably have the big picture. You need the details and there are jarring gaps and red flags in the whole story, but basically you have the big picture: Your wife was in an active affair. It was physical. It would probably be ongoing hadn’t you stopped it.
That’s enough for now. That’s enough to work with.
Over or under panties isn’t really an issue NOW. Oral or panties or dress, what she did or did not do with OM… not an issue NOW. Getting to the bottom of all the relevant issues takes time and contemplation. The truth needs to be known and each element needs to be analyzed and digested, but at the correct time.
I am NOT suggesting or advocating rug-sweeping. Just that you rest, think, analyze, ask, confirm, rest, analyze, ask again, confirm… if needed. Once again – pace yourself. You will get the truth you need, and you NEED the truth… but not necessarily right now.
Be as true and honest to yourself as you can.
Earlier on you said your wife could easily be replaced. You called her a bitch. You said that what you already knew is a deal-breaker and you were going to divorce.
Yet here you are…
First days or even weeks are controlled by emotions and anger. One more reason to pace yourself.
If you want to divorce, then you already have all you need. I have seen posters divorce from what would be considered “less” than you are dealing with, I have seen posters recover from “more”. Doesn’t matter. What matters is what YOU want and what YOU can get. Be it D or be it R.
What would be the absolute worst outcome IMHO is some quasi-marriage where the issues aren’t resolved. Either because your wife minimizes or doesn’t deal with what made her decide to have an affair, or because you replace marriage with a form of servitude and submission.
So be as true and honest to yourself as you can. Be clear on your goals and what you hope to strive for. You are perfectly free to change goals and/or adjust as you go along, but working towards D requires different tools than working to R.
BTW – I left my relationship and have never bothered getting to know why my fiancé had this need to have sex with random men. For ME – at THAT TIME and at THAT PLACE in our relationship the simple fact she had sex with other men was enough. Getting to know or understand why wouldn’t have changed my mind. What she did with them and what she wore… for me at that time had no relevance to my decision.
Regarding a poly.
I recommend you get one. Only use it correctly. Use it to CONFIRM you have the truth.
If you entertain some thoughts of reconciling, then this is what I recommend:
Tell your wife you need total and absolute honesty. Promise her that whatever she shares NOW and in the next week or so will be received and digested. There will be no knee-jerk reaction, no filing for divorce, no racing to OM to give him a beating. Right now, you aren’t certain if you can reconcile or not, but you will take whatever she shares and contemplate what you want to do.
Make it extremely clear that if you discover any direct lies or (major) omissions they will have immense negative impact. They will hammer in the truth that you can’t trust her, and that she doesn’t trust you with the truth. A small lie uncovered later can be more damaging than a major confession now.
At some point IF you decide to reconcile – probably no earlier than late January – you do a poly with the main aim of confirming what truths you already have. Like if she tells you that their first date was on XX and you have proof that it’s correct then one of the questions might be on that subject.
Finally, regarding the poly: It needs to have a purpose. We had a poster earlier this year whose wife insisted nothing physical happened. This despite overwhelming evidence where even I the sceptic was certain it was physical. The wife miserably failed a poly – like totally flunked it 100%. The BH didn’t have a clear path so last time he posted he was still trying to reconcile with a wayward wife that refused to tell him the truth. I can’t imagine growing old with a spouse that I constantly doubt. So, use the poly as a milestone: If she passes you believe what she has told you, if she fails then she doesn’t trust you and R isn’t really a feasible or attainable option.