Hi there. I’ve been away from SI for a while. About 2 1/2 months. I’ve stayed in touch only a bit by PMing with a couple of members and reading thru threads of BS’s that I felt were truly engaged in their recovery (of whatever form that took for them) after infidelity.
N, you and your thread definitely fit that profile and I’ve been hopeful you’d be able to find a path that suits you and gives you some much needed peace in your journey toward recovery.
What you have learned since DDay is very painful. I don’t diminish that pain one bit. I’m sorry you have had to endure it so.
With that said, I’m back to say something that I know will be unpopular. It’s a perspective that somewhat caused my break from SI to begin with. But after staying in touch with your thread during my “sabbatical” I think it’s important that I give a voice to the thoughts I have when I read your and others’ posts of the last few days.
N, I see remorse in your wife. I honest to god do. It’s not fully formed yet, but I think she feels it to a great extent. She has pain in her heart for how this has hurt you. She doesn’t always know how to handle it, but it’s there.
I do see why others don’t. She withheld information which continued to hurt you. And of course that’s absolutely the wrong thing to do. But my feeling is the overriding reason that she did so was because she really really couldn’t bear to hurt you any more.
Sure, I can see why you and others would deem that as making her a non remorseful WS. She made the decision for you. She did that in a unilateral way. That was wrong and also makes her continue to be considered to be Wayward. I do think think that was a wayward action to a great extent.
But I don’t think that excludes her from being remorseful.
Here is the thing. She didn’t do this to hold on to the affair. In my opinion she wasn’t withholding the details to protect them as special. I really believe she hates every single memory of the A and they continue to wreck her daily. Nor do I think she cares anymore for her AP. I don’t think she was trying to protect him one bit.
No, instead she did it because she saw the condition the information she had already relayed to you put you in. She could see how it had destroyed you already and couldn’t bear the thought of piling on to that. I think she really feared what it would do to you. I think in her way she cared what that would do to you.
Everyone told her to tell u everything. And she was wrong not to. It was cowardly not to. But I truly believe she couldn’t bear to. You can call it cowardice and you wouldn’t be wrong.
But honestly, even though I am not a WS, it’s what i absolutely could see me doing if I were one, especially without the 3 yrs of experience I have on SI.
I would feel the urge to deflect and minimize. I couldn’t and wouldn’t be able to stand the thought of what telling the details would do to the person I loved. It would make me nauseous each piece of awful detail I would have to relay. And I’d try desperately not to do it even if others told me to.
I would know logically that I should, from listening to the good advice from posters on Wayward Side, and i hope I would power thru it and give the things to my BS that I thought they needed, but I am sure it would be a real struggle to do so, especially if I saw how destroyed they were each time I relayed those new awful details. In the end I’d know I’d have to and so did she. And she did. She could have just rejected the Poly and told you she couldn’t do it. But she didn’t. She wanted a chance to repair.
N, we have seen here WS’s who wouldn’t do it because they Just did not care enough. Or they wanted to protect their APs. Many have told their BS to “just get over it”.
I don’t think your WW has said that once to you. I think she has honestly tried to learn what she should be doing. I don’t think she’s done it all, but she has wanted to learn. To me that’s the start of rebuilding.
And I think when she started telling you more the last few weeks, it was not only because of Poly panic, but because some of what she was being told by experienced BS’s and WS’s truly started to seep thru the thick veneer she put up to protect her psyche from the pain she caused you.
In fact, (get your arrows and stones ready folks) I personally believe you have someone who is remorseful, empathetic for the pain you are in, and truthful in the love she has for you.
I fear I’m gonna get killed for saying that. I hope not.
N, She is awful at expressing it. And too often she gets scared about what’s going to happen to her and what her life is gonna be like. But I think her heart aches for you. I really do.
Now does that mean you have to try and rebuild your marriage? Nope.
What she did was a full blown affair and if that’s a deal breaker for you and believe you won’t and can’t live with a person who did that to you, then absolutely separate and file when ready. You have every right and if that’s what you need to get out from under the great pain she has put in you then that’s the path you need to follow.
But my opinion is that if you want a chance at a life with her, and do love her, and feel it’s worth the time and effort (great effort) to get there, then you definitely have a willing partner.
N, sometimes love isn’t enough. I’ve msg’d with BS posters like WWTL plenty enough about their stories and to know that to be completely true.
But I also know that some of our greatest WS rebuilders TT’d and deflected and minimized for weeks or months before coming clean and showing full remorse. Not one of them was perfect in their response.
And not one of them handled recovery perfectly. Even when they desired reconciliation they made more mistakes in that process than successful actions. They said stupid things and they took twenty steps back before finally taking two steps forward.
But they had the will and determination to work to become better people than they were before the A and prove to their BS’s that if they stuck with them it would be worth the journey (which would last their lifetime).
I’m also going to disagree this was an exit affair. To me if it was, that meant she was looking to end your marriage and had an affair to make you D her.
I don’t think she wanted that one bit. I don’t think she wanted to leave you.
I think she was missing something in herself and had no idea what, but because of the lousy communication abilities she grew up with, and actually exhibited the whole time since you married, including when she should have told you she was hurt in the past and worked together on those issues, she had absolutely no skills in how to talk to you about that. She Had no idea how to even have that discussion.
So instead she found what she felt she was lacking ... in the form of someone else. And she used him for that.
But I don’t think she wanted to leave you for him. I believe during the A she wanted both. She wanted her cake. She found a way to fill the missing gaps in her life that she had in her mind and still be able to stay with you. She didn’t want a life away from you at all. She wanted to live as the center of the world for both men. Why not, during that time things felt good.
So no, i don’t believe this was an exit affair. But it was a shitty affair yes. And one that is perfectly valid for you to decide you can’t live with and be in a relationship the person who perpetrated it.
Of course you are the decider here. I believe you to be a thoughtful man. I believe if you think there is a chance you’ll communicate with her what you need to see and hear to even attempt to rebuild and then get started.
But I honestly think you need time to decide what it is you want. Sure if you need time apart for a while, separating is valid. Perhaps you both need time to work on yourselves and figure out who you are going to both be going forward.
But I know your DD is part of that equation, and if you want some time to see if your feelings for your W can overcome the pain that has been inflicted, then perhaps not upending your D’s world by having mom and dad live separately is a better path, instead by staying together and doing real work while you have the opportunity see if you can make some progress on healing.
It’s up to you completely. Now that you know what I believe is the whole story I think it appropriate for you to take some time and sit back and evaluate what you really want from life going forward. That does not need to be rushed.
There will be lots of requirements for her in rebuilding. I believe she has it in her to do so, even though many here will probably disagree. That’s ok. But I think she badly wants the chance to prove that to you.
In the end I just wanted my ideas to be represented here. I think they are in the minority, but that’s ok. I have seen a few provide similar thoughts and possibilities. So I don’t feel totally in left field.
I just wanted you to know that some of the things that were being said about your WW I personally did not agree with. I understood these ideas, but I think there is more depth to what she is exhibiting than a completely inward focused person.
Anyway, if anything I’ve said resonated, and you want to discuss, I’m glad to. But if not, that’s completely understandable ... please move on to the next poster and I’ll take a step back again.
Good luck on this continued awful journey. I wish you the best life you can possibly have going forward.
[This message edited by Stevesn at 11:55 AM, October 17th (Thursday)]