You are far more likely to get the unvarnished truth on SI as all sides and levels of awareness are represented. Reddit's adultery section is as honest and self-aware as Tinder. Remember that.
It's all filters. On Reddit, there's really no filter, and people say all manner of insanity. :) But, let's be honest with ourselves here, we are self-selecting heavily in this group. I know/have known, IDK, maybe 10 male cheats in my life. 0 have talked about FOO. 0 have talked about leaving their wives, their deep conflicts, their desperate situations or their unhappiness with life. Almost all of them have raved about sex with the AP(s).
AFAIK, in the few years I've been here, we've never had a poster come here and say "The sex with my AP was so much better, I just don't know what to do". Maybe they have, but I've never seen it. However, again, intellectual honesty here, what would we say to that poster? I'm quite certain I know what message would be delivered, and it's not one that I'd want to receive. We're a group of people with a common purpose, trying to heal from the wounds of an A, and because of that, we're "on message" most of the time.
I think I've mentioned this in other threads, but I used to have a drinking problem as a young man. I spent some time in AA as a result of my issues and the repercussions from them, and, when you step into those rooms, it's much like this one. It's very self-selected. You won't hear "war stories" about the awesome time RIO and his buddies went fishing, got drunk and wound up having a great time. Nor will you hear stories about how great 12 year old scotch tastes. It's entirely focused on the negative, and the repercussions of that drinking rather than the pleasure and enjoyment obtained from that activity. But you get those guys alone, sometimes you'll get a different story, a story about how much they miss it, how much they wish they could still drink and keep it under control, and how, while their life is better today, they still think about it often. In AA, they call it "dry drunk", someone who wants to drink and misses it, but does not, and, in my experience, it's quite common. However, in the "room", there's none of that. The message is curated and when people talk, they know "what to say". In many ways, A recovery is similar, there are things you say, and there are things you do not say. In the "do not say" group comes much of the things that you see on Reddit, best sex of my life, best orgasms, so much better in bed than my BS, etc. Is it always true on Reddit? No, of course not. Is it sometimes true? Of course it is, there's a reason that some people (me, for example) worry about it, and it's not because we're crazy people and not because we need to spend more time in psych's office. It happens. Is it common? IDK. Before my W's A and before coming here, I would have told you "Having an A appears to be, from 1st hand reports, the best sex in the world". Because that's what I heard most commonly from other men. Confounding that, some of what other men told me was true; "Married women go from hello to the bedroom quick, they get down to business, there are no limits with them in bed, etc". All of that, at least in my personal situation, pretty much dead on accurate.
I certainly wouldn't suggest anyone spend a lot of time there, it's horrifying. But I also don't think it's make believe, at least not most of it. Honestly, I wish my W stumbled on that /r/ before her affair, she would have understood the dynamics of what she was entering into and the mentality of at least some male APs (and certainly hers, he would be a "reddit original") so much better.
[This message edited by Rideitout at 6:37 PM, July 6th (Monday)]