Thanks all, let me try to respond to the questions above.
1. Regarding reverse prenup, I know it wouldn't hold up in court, but thats not really the point. I was trying to gauge his interest level.
2. I do not at all agree with his infidelity for the 1st marriage. Please believe that. I know all WS say the same crap. I do have evidence though that they were in counseling for years and neither one of them were happy - again this doesn't condone the cheating. I do know that they separated before she knew about the cheating.
3. He does do facetime, check ins, photos of who he's with, etc.
4. The house is in his name, not mine. Financially I am fine though - he hasnt "taken" anything from me and I'm not on the hook. I made a point to not have my name on things if we weren't married.
5. The OW never called him her boyfriend. They had an entanglement a few years ago and they were never really together, frankly I think they both used each other to make themselves feel desirable. From what I read in text messages, etc. it was a very volatile relationship - they argued a lot - no one was committed to the other. It most certainly was an EA though.
I know it sounds crazy to want to work on R. Honestly, I think the reason I do is we have a child together, he seems remorseful and is doing a lot of work. It's been hard no doubt, and i know R isn't a cakewalk. I know I can change my mind and leave any time. But I have been single before this, for many, many years. And honestly? I don't want to be alone. He treats me well outside of the whole cheating BS and we have a good life together. He seems very committed to me and a good father. We were very concerned after our daughter was born that she had a fatal disease and it was a few months of very scary stuff. He was really wonderful through all that. In a way, it sorta put things in perspective in terms of what's important - for both of us.
If I had found out about it and he was still communicating with her when I found out - that may be a different story. But he did end it before I found out, he doesn't get brownie points for that but it confirms - somewhat - that he wanted out and wanted to end it - without me telling him to do so. I can see through records she tried to text him a couple of times but he never responded - he went complete NC. So I think he's genuine about being done with that.
Listen, I know it's bad. I hate it and it's not what I want. I'm like, seriously I'm here AGAIN!? But I want a family - I want this family. I'm 40, I've lived a lot. There are a lot of dirt bags out there, and ones that never try to fix their shit. I realize he was an asshole and maybe he still is, but he seems to be working on stuff. I'm certainly not living in a fantasy, I know it's work and frankly, it's shitty to go through this again - but maybe it's the devil ya know. :Shrug: Plus, the thought was we can get to a more honest place by going through this storm. I know he's working on himself a lot.
Do you think I should still ask for a poly this far down the line? I only brought it up back then and frankly haven't thought about it since. Part of the reason is we went into a deep dive and his own IC, etc. and talked about "Limerance" which is basically when someone can crave and want the attention of someone, but it isn't necessarily sexual or physical in nature. It seemed to be a lot of that. I could write more but trust me when I say we talked about it to death. And maybe he did but he swears up and down, he didn't. Anyways, the way he talks about things now, he knows he's being checked up on, etc. but he says he's been showing every day he's putting in the work and why go backwards and keep reliving stuff. Is there an argument for watering the flowers and not the weeds?
[This message edited by NewMomNeedingAdvice at 2:47 AM, Tuesday, August 24th]