SisterMilkshake- continuing to promote the stereotype that sex workers are "broken" is actively harmful to them.
Well, I don't get shocked much here, but this one really did shock me. I really thought that the brainwashing of society on this particular issue was "complete" and nobody could say anything like this anymore, but.. Well, here it is.
Of course SOME sex workers are broken people. Drug addicts, terrible childhoods, mental/emotional issues. I'd even go so far as to say "A significantly higher percentage than the general population" would fit that description. But not all. I also knew a few, mostly girls from college who, right after school, did some pay for play stuff. Ranging from the very, very early "cam girls" days all the way to full-time escorting. I honestly couldn't tell you much difference between them and any other girl I knew (or dated). They had good, decent, bad, and awful childhoods. Some finished college, some didn't. All of that, AFAIK, did it for a period of time and then stopped. I really don't know if they enjoyed the work or not, I suspect, much like any other job where you deal with random customers, sometimes they did, sometimes they didn't. And I'm sure, to keep this somewhat on topic, they all provided "pornstar sex" to their customers.
Now, this isn't without it's problems, that I admit. Making sex work entirely legal is, without question in my mind, the right thing to do. It's insanity to say that you can commit a crime by monetizing your body in only one particular way. Want to get shot at for money? No problem, there's the recruiter over there. Want to work in a mine, on an oil rig, as a lumberjack. No problem have at it, and make sure you have good health insurance (those jobs are the "most dangerous jobs" by injury/death rates).
However, sex work being entirely legal does, IMHO, tear at the fabric of society in very deep and meaningful ways. There's an issue right now with men having a "failure to launch" and not expressing much interest in relationships with women, eschewing romance for porn and video games. I'm not sure how "real" that is, but the birth stats/marriage stats are absolutely telling us "something" is happening. And legal prostitution will only accelerate that trend away from relationships to "single serving size" transactional relationships, IMHO. It's a problem, or a possible one that I can certainly foresee if sex becomes commonly bought/sold.
We will see, it certainly feels like the tide is moving to more and more permissive attitudes about sex for sale. But saying that every or even most prostitutes are "broken people" just doesn't seem to encompass those I know who've done it. It's a crappy job with significant risk (much of it because of it's illegality) that pays very, very well. There's a whole line of jobs that meet that description, I really have trouble distinguishing why this one is so different.
And, a little thought experiment for you. Where are all the stories about "broken" and trafficked male prostitutes? Or do they not exist? Are men somehow immune to this? Which, I honestly find very funny, a whole lot of male prostitutes are "gay for pay", which, as a straight man, sounds like, well, one of the worst jobs imaginable. And somehow, it seems that almost nobody really cares about that; is it only broken women who become professionals, where men, hey, it's just another career choice? Or is it because we know that sex is somehow different for men, even sleeping with their "non-preferred" gender is somehow less "damaging" than a woman doing the same with her preferred gender?
There have been studies that show that BDSM practitioners tend to be mentally healthier and have better and more fulfilling relationships.
Well, hey, I've got that going for at least, one thing pointing to "mentally healthy". Plenty of things pointing the opposite way though, so I'm not sure that weighs out! ;)
I'm not shocked by this though, it often seems when I used to meet people into "alternative sex" they were well grounded people. I always remember hearing "it's the people you least suspect" who are into all manners of kink, and, I think that might be more true than I thought as a younger man. It's always the quiet ones! ;)
[This message edited by Rideitout at 6:17 PM, October 14th (Monday)]