You have been hammered with so much information and so many suggestions that I can’t imagine you can cope with it all. You must be physically exhausted and that diminishes your capability to handle this situation. If you can then tell her not to come over right now, order in and try to get some sleep.
I’m going to suggest you take some time and THINK.
I strongly recommend that you only work with what you know.
You know enough already. You know your wife is having an affair. You know where it took place and who he is. What you don’t know is the extent of the affair and you don’t have a believable timeline.
However, … You do have a tremendous tool in her phone and once you have that data you can corroborate it with her story and other evidence. There are other tools you can dig into: bank accounts, her work e-mail, possibly HR, her boss… But I think once you evaluate what the phone gives you then you will probably have a clear picture.
Aa an experienced investigator then I saw holes in a lot of what you shared regarding what happened at the party. Holes don’t mean the signs are wrong, only they might be read in more ways than one. However, the fact she hid his contact info under Jennifer… THAT is the clincher. That is the smoking gun. After all – if it was all innocent and “not what you think” then why not just use his real name?
If you read the suggestions offered, then IMHO there is no way you can avoid going crazy with concerns:
OM is in a hotel – now he’s in a house – no it’s the bosses house – boss is in on it…
She needs to resign – now her resignation is an indicator that the affair was deeper than she has shared…
The timeline can’t be correct… It’s fast, but a lot of what we already know supports the timeline might be reasonably accurate.
If she talks to him alone at the party, it’s an affair – if they talk in a group they are all in on it…
She met him in her former job (as if all companies are hiring the same Canadian French IT project manager…)
They must have had sex. No way to avoid that…
It’s ALL SPECULATION at best – unnecessarily making things worse at worst.
Deal with what you KNOW. It’s bad enough already without having to deal with more than you can conjure up in your imagination.
Realize that as you go along you will learn more – that in turn will help you with getting even more. This will take some days before you will feel like you have a clear picture.
Keep in mind that IF you decide you want to reconcile then it needs to be done on a basis of truth.
IF you decide to reconcile she needs to tell you EVERYTHING and at the level of detail you need. The truth will come out. Heck… even IF she tells you everything now it’s likely that tidbits – even important ones – will be dropping for the next couple of months.
You don’t need to decide now if you want to divorce or reconcile, but if you are decided on D then some of the actions taken are not to your advantage. Like her job. If you are committed to divorce, then it’s to your advantage that she has a job.
Early on in this thread you used some words that make me think you are inclined to divorce. You mention how easily you can replace your wife and you call her a bitch. Maybe that was posted in the heat of the moment, but If those sentiments are true then I’m going to suggest you divorce.
There is talk of punishment. I wish it was so simple. You can’t whip her or make her run laps or sit in a corner. She needs to face consequences and some of them will be harmful, but there really isn’t any punishment. If you want to divorce then do so because you want to divorce, not to punish her. If you want to reconcile then EVENTUALLY, the work required for R should create a good marriage. But don’t underestimate how much work that is…
When you meet her (and I suggest you first get some sleep) then the main thing is to listen. You should be listening for at least 90% of the time. Sit at opposite side of a table. Make this business-like. Take notes. Print out some e-mails and have them face-down under your notebook. When she says something, you aren’t certain about then look at the e-mail and ask her if she’s sure about what she said. Be dead-calm.
If the talk is going in a direction you don’t like, then call a time-out. Go get a drink of water or whatever. Just get out of the situation to cool down and think.
There are a couple of statements you might want to have ready:
“The only way this marriage has even the slightest chance of recovering is if you tell me the total truth. Be careful – I already have a lot of evidence and what I have is more believable and reliable than you. I will also be getting further corroboration. Be aware that if I discover some discrepancies in your story and what I know or will find it’s going to cause immense damage to any chance of reconciliation.”
“No – Me being distant/unemotionally available/bad in the sack (or whatever excuse she puts here) is not why you needed to have an affair. The affair and the decision to have an affair is totally 100% your fault and you can’t use me or our marriage as an excuse. If you do that it will only enforce my doubts that this can be saved”
Focus on getting FACTS and a good timeline. If you can avoid getting into the why’s. It’s too early for those.