When I say fake, I think there may be some who are trolls but I think the majority are playing to their audience.
I'm sure you're right, but, again, this is exactly the problem. Those WS's are embellishing, my W (and waywards at recovery sites like this) are likely downplaying. This is why lying is bad, in case anyone wants to know.
If I could trust my W's answers, it doesn't really matter what the A reddit says, does it? I'd know the truth. But I cannot, because, well, she has massive incentive to lie and really no way for me to ever call her on the lie. The A reddit has much less incentive to lie, so I tend to trust it more, sure, probably some chest thumping and bravado, but I imagine the general context of their content to be at least somewhat accurate. And in the huge gulf between the two (best sex of my life to it was awful/couldn't get it up/etc), somewhere in there, floats the truth for any individual affair. But if everyone is lying, well, you'll never know what you're dealing with in a WS, if it's important to you.
Thankfully a WS who has spoken the truth. The affair sex is good, otherwise why keep going back.
Well, see it a little different. "Going back for more" doesn't necessarily mean "good" to me. What makes it hard to believe it wasn't at least "very good" is simply the nature of the relationship and the typical "nothing withheld" nature of it. A forbidden relationship, in secret, kept apart by others, only able to meet occasionally, plenty of build up between encounters.. I mean, that reads like a typical romance novel. And then, on the other side, the "everything goes"/wild/kinky/uninhibited sex, well, that read like a typical porn plot. I mean, these are fantasies being acted out in real life, "I'm so hot he'll cheat on his wife for me" and "She's so into me I can get anal behind the bleachers". It's really goddarn hard to see how with all those elements "going for it" that at least some of the /r/a stuff is accurate.
As a WS I see myself in those posts. When I as IN my affair, those posts reflect exactly how I felt. Its painful to read it. I don't think its made up, I think its how they truly feel, in the moment. Everything is heightened. I don't understand why BS are so adamant that it all has to be fake and nothing is that great, I know its easier to say that, but realistically affair sex is different. And unless you have experienced it, its hard to understand it. I can tell you in the moment, it does feel that way. That's why affairs are so addicting and hard to untangle from. Its a high.
Thank you for your honesty, and yes, this reads a lot more reasoned to me than either what I heard from my W or what I read in /r/a. However, I'm not at all convinced "it's all fake" (unless your talking about love in an A, I'm pretty sure that's usually fake to get the other AP to give up sex), in fact, I think the opposite, I don't think the "fireworks" sex is fake at all, in fact, I know that's a big draw for those I've known looking for or having affairs. They sure as heck aren't talking about how much fun it is to TXT their AP's all night long, I can tell you that much.