The story and situation has a lot of holes.
1. How would she feel like she might have deep feelings for this guy over a drunken one-night stand?
2. Why isn't she overly sorry considering that she was so wracked with guilt that she confessed over the advice of her therapist. And it seems that she is on the speed button for the therapist, calling constantly and quoting on the therapists advice. Pile on with that, no STD test? If she was so guilt-ridden, wouldn't she had done that right away before even having sex with you?
3. Then, over a drunken-one night stand, she is unsure of whether to stay married with you. Does this seem as odd to you as it seems to me?
4. Piling on a little more, she immediately went to a therapist over a drunken one-night stand? Really? How about going to Alcoholics Anonymous? What is a therapist going to do about her drinking problem?
5. She had a drunken one-night stand and the reason is? Top item on the board is ...? Too little time with my husband. So she had a one-night drunken stand because you didn't spend enough time with her. If you had, then she would not have drank and not had sex one night. Really? Please.
That's for starters. That's before even the only one time sex story (the number one lie I see here is "didn't have sex (i.e., "only kissing.") the number two lie I see here is "only one time." Lucky you, she must have found a two-for-one coupon, because you got both of the top lies I see here.)
Or, just perhaps, there are a few little lies. Fibs. Cheaters have been known to do that.
Where have you been getting your information? From her? Where she's been? Relationship status of other man? How long it's been going on? Do you have any evidence other than her word?
I'll cut off for now. Except to say that you are doing it all wrong. There are guys here who are reconciled with their wives after being cheated on, I reconciled with my wife, and just about all of them I know of acted very decisively to end the affair, get the truth, and figure out what's wrong. The other ones by and large wandered around in the desert looking for water and hoping to find some. Hoping is not a plan. What is your plan?
The longer you act like your wife believes her cheating was acceptable, the longer she will become set in her mind that it actually was acceptable. For a whole lot of reasons, but think about this: What attracted you to your wife, and how does that compare to how you act now, and how does the other man act? Do you think other man is afraid to lose your wife and refrains his real feelings because he might lose her?
You are afraid of what your wife might act if you ask her to take a polygraph? And you think she might leave if you "invade her privacy." Yup, them's divorcing words. But having sex with another guy, risking your health and life over a disease - you're OK with that. If she "invaded your privacy," would you want to divorce her?
[This message edited by wk55hn at 7:42 PM, September 21st (Wednesday)]