It's tough to watch you flounder around. Your wife can find the other man's wife. Your wife must have studied the other man's wife. Your wife was in love for three years with the poor woman's husband. Just like other man knew all about you, the competition. He got the play-by-play of your sexual exploits, in writing no less, so he could out-do you. I don't know what your wife must be thinking about. She must see what you are trying to do and failing miserably - is she happy about that? I think so, she still loves other man, and probably I think must have warned you would be trying to contact other man's wife.
Just get a private investigator and do this. You had money for IVF, you had money for a wedding, setting up a life - and you have at this time an other man who claimed he wouldn't stop contacting your wife, and that "I understand" to the no contact after all that other bluster, just makes me think she cued him in this was coming and just call uncle so my husband let's this go.
As far as claiming this was 9 months of this and it was off and then back on, I call bullshit. Your wife was in love with this guy the whole time, the whole three years, and as far as I can see, still is to this very day. This thing can come back and boomerang you at any moment.
What do you want?
I did not want the same thing as you, I think, but I did want my wife and my family intact IF, AND ONLY IF, my wife wanted that too. So I told my wife I wanted other man's workplace name, address, phone number, and other man's wife email and Facebook and other man's address and phone - and she gave it to me. That was probably about 30 minutes after I first confronted my wife.
The first thing I did was tell my wife that I knew, which she denied about a minute or two, then told me they were just friends a minute or two, which I just told her please go be with him, I'll call him up myself and tell him he wins, you're coming, I'll help you pack, bag and baggage. Then she started crying hysterically with snot blowing out of her nose and hyperventilating and I thought for a second or two that I might have to call 911 because she didn't seem like she could breathe.
A day or two on, I called other man's job and told them I found a whole lot of raunchy stuff on his work email and asked him to get fired or I'd have to look into their culpability in allowing employees to do such things so frequently and so long, then after he was fired I called him up to gloat and tell him he can let this be the end or else somehow his past mistakes might follow him elsewhere.
So I don't understand the slow response, not just you but in general. If you love your wife and you want this to end, then do the things that need to be done to end it. She's come back to him twice already, and at the time when she was madly and passionately making love to you, which tells you something.
So put a bomb in other man's life - can you believe the fucking balls on that guy, when your wife told him you found out, he said he won't end it anyway - he treats you like nothing, he has no care in the world that you won't rock his world.
At the very least, go tell the guy's wife. A private investigator is expensive. A divorce is even more expensive.
edited, yes, I got a private investigator and found out even more dirt on the scumbag who cheated with my wife. One result from that, even more so than I already had felt, was couldn't she even cheat on me with a half-way decent guy? How bad must I be if she wanted this guy?
[This message edited by wk55hn at 11:31 AM, April 30th (Sunday)]