These following statements do not. They blameshift onto the spouse/marriages where the blame does not go. These statements suggest that if the spouse does not ignore the WS, then they will not be vulnerable (still BS) to choosing to hurt other people.
I know we (not specifically you and I, but lots of us) disagree on these points, but I can't hold myself out as "blameless" for what happened in my marriage. It's just a fact, in my eyes, that there are things that can make an A less likely, and things that can make an A more likely. Deployed for 6 months behind enemy lines while your wife is at home alone? Well, yes, that's much more likely to result in an affair than the husband who's home every night at 6 for dinner and to put the kids to bed. I'm not arguing it's "right", but it's reality. Travel a lot for work? Increases your chances. Drink too much? Too heavy? Don't pay attention to your H/W? All things that increase your chances. It leaves the other person more open to the possibility of having an A, right, wrong, otherwise, it just does. The best analogy I can think of, you take a broke person with no cash who's starving to death and put him in the middle of grocery store, well, that person has a MUCH higher chance than a randomly selected person of stealing something from that store. Yes, it's still their fault, and yes, they deserve to be punished, but, at the same time, saying that person is "as likely" to steal as the person walking through with a Gucci handbag holding their black card is simply burying your head in the sand.
Frankly, if there is "nothing you can do" to reduce the chances of cheating in your spouse, that feels horribly defeatist and "random walk" to me. Why not marry a rock star then? Or some who's cheated on their past 9 husbands? I mean, we can say "we all have an equal chance of it" but.. We really don't. Very attractive people have more opportunity. Women have vastly more offers. And so on. But if it's all just a random walk, there's no "good way" to protect yourself from infidelity. My wife is as likely to cheat today as she was the day she cheated. And I don't believe that. I think I've taken actions that make it less likely to happen again, things I've done to help improve our relationship (as she has). Things that help insulate me from an A. Perfect, no. Does it change the odds? I think it takes an active denial of reality to claim otherwise.
I often come back to the analogy of wearing a seatbelt when discussing this. Are seatbelt's going to stop all death in cars? No, not at all. But, does it stop a lot of them? Yes, it does. And to continue this analogy, before the A, I was tooling around at 50MPH with 4 bald tires and no seatbelt. I wasn't taking the care that I should have with my M. And I got into a terrible accident when some idiot drifted into my lane. The accident was CLEARLY not my fault. But the damage from that accident didn't need to be as severe as it was. If I had a seatbelt on, I wouldn't need years of reconstructive surgery. And if I'd had good tires, I probably could have stopped fast enough to prevent the accident entirely.
So, today, I make sure I have my 5 point harness on and brand new tires with all the safety features in my new car. Which is something that I should have done before, but I just thought "it won't be me" as I tooled around town. It shouldn't have been me. I'm a good driver, and I wasn't doing anything wrong. But the severity of those injuries, well.. While the accident wasn't my fault, I certainly did have control over that part of it.
There are some people who are going to cheat no matter what. Sex 8 times a day with every kink you can imagine, still seeing prostitutes. Husband does the dishes, validates you non-stop, is supportive, brings home great money, still sleeping with gardener. There are cases like this, I've read about them here. Those aren't mine. I know I could have done better. It only takes about 10 seconds to look back on my pre-A marriage and think "wow, that was a stupid thing to say/do" and "that probably really pushed her away/hurt her". If I'd not done those things, would she have still had an A? I don't know. But I do know, at the margins, it matters. If there's a spectrum of cheaters from "will cheat every chance they get" to "will only cheat if their husband is in a coma and will never wake up and need someone to comfort them" which I believe there is then the question becomes, am I married to someone who's in the first category or the 2nd. My WW is closer to the 2nd. Most of my male friends are closer to the first. But thinking that "nothing I do matters" just.. Well, it doesn't work for me.
Leaving out arguments in blame (of course the cheater is responsible) it is also an easily verifiable statistical fact. You can see it every day. Captain Rogers saw it.
Of course it is (both easily verifiable and also a statistical fact). Our actions matter, BS or not. Teat your spouse like s**t, well, guess what? It increases the likely hood of both an A and D. Treat them great, decreases both. Away for work 6 months at a time? Same story. We can not want this to be the case, but, if our actions don't matter, well, that's about the saddest thing I've ever heard. "Just pray on it" would be my advice if we really can't impact the outcome at all, but I DO NOT feel that my M, or really any M, falls into this category at all. There are a lot of things we can do to make it better, and, for some people, that will be enough to keep them from cheating. I'll never get on board with this "blameless" BS (even though it would be nice for me to believe that personally) or, more correctly, the "totally powerless BS". Bulls**t. I shouldn't have been subject to this, and I certainly didn't deserve it, but I did have the power to change it (pre-A). And I have the power to change it today (and feel that I have) post-A.
[This message edited by Rideitout at 10:36 AM, June 20th (Thursday)]