You have to understand your WH thinking is delusional. His brain has been so saturated in drugs and alcohol for who knows how long? Your WH doesn't even know himself. Heck, the way I see it, none of you know yourselves because the focus has been on him for so long and trying to get him to straighten out.
The truth probably is that he doesn't remember that night and many other nights like this. Only we get to remember. This part has been so frustrating for me. We are the one's who endured the abuse yet they don't remember a lot or most of it. It took me a long time to come to this acceptance.
When I read that letter I saw many things in it. I saw fear. I saw sadness. I saw pain. I saw manipulation. I saw him wanting to convince you, you know, like the old day's, that this time change is for real...I saw lots of emotions. I saw that he can't live his life without you. Not too sure what that means. You know him best...how did you read into the letter?
My other thought is that in AA when alcoholics become sober they learn about themselves through a 12 step program. They also learn that although they may not remember their past because they were so drunk or high, the fact is that they left a "trail of destruction" to clean up.
This means coming to terms and making amends for all the awful things they did in the past but do not remember or even do remember but the moods of the alcohol or drugs created monster behavior in them. This is a sober man's (and women's) reality. This is part of their coming out of denial and into reality.
I believe that this is where many alcoholic/drug addicts fail to stay sober because the past that they created is so devastating that they can't deal with, so they go back to the lifestyle that kept them in denial in the first place. In your WH case, it was alcohol, drugs, bars and women and who knows what else? Then history repeats itself and back on the merry go round we go again.
You said that you aren't afraid of him and that you refuse to leave your home or your lifestyle behind but you also know and must realize that this thorn will never go away because he is your children's father.
You more than likely will see him somewhere down the line...holiday's, birthday's, etc. You can not sweep this under the rug.
You and your kid's are close knit and they love their father and his behavior is all they know. I would think the best thing to do is to come together with your kids, spouses, your father, (what about his parents and siblings?) and discuss the next actions. Maybe some type of intervention and let him know there are ground rules that can not ever be crossed again or there will be consequences. I think you all (and esp you) will have the answer. But this decision has to be everyone is all in on the joint decisions. This situation is dire!
One last thing, I strongly recommended AA mens groups, or there is CR, Celebrate Recovery, SA groups, counseling and whatever else. This is for your kid's father. He pretty much should be doing something 7 day's a week for a long time, and maybe continue attending the program for the rest of his life. This really should be a stipulation for him to stay out of jail.
You and your kid's attend Alanon, they will embrace you. It's one of the best things I did for myself. It's also a 12 step program. It brought me out of denial and helped me find myself.
[This message edited by Hurtmyheart at 6:25 PM, September 24th (Tuesday)]