AH
I’m going to admit that I have mostly stayed off your threads because I saw such immense indecisiveness. I’m OK with people stating they want to reconcile and I’m OK with people stating they want to divorce. I’m even OK with people stating that they don’t know what to do.
What I don’t like is people stating they are working at divorce and then doing all the actions of reconciliation. Nor people that state they want to reconcile and do all the D work. I sort of think that if you commit to a path you need to focus on that path – with reasonable attention to your other options and always with a clear path and milestones to evaluate progress on.
If you want to reconcile then that’s your choice.
Plenty of posters here on SI that think it’s not possible. Some might grudgingly acknowledge that sometimes it just might theoretically be possible for some. Some will tell you that those that claim to have reconciled are simply weaned onto a diet of shit-sandwiches. Yet at the same time all those posters will be spewing their logic on this site, founded by a couple that reconciled. Basically enjoying the hospitality of a man they think feeds on shit-sandwiches.
So yes – R is possible.
Only it’s not easy, nor is there any guarantee whatsoever that it will ever be successful.
But then – there are plenty of people that claim to have divorced, yet years later they post about how their ex is marrying or meeting someone else or whatever. That’s not divorce. Or people that scream at you to divorce while hanging in some limbo that’s neither reconciliation nor divorce. Often justified with claims of not affording D or the present hell being best for the kids or waiting for their attorneys to place a value on the used mower to ensure they get exactly half it’s value. Basically, it’s like a parachutist hanging onto the plane yet claiming he plans to let go – even if the plane has already landed again.
What I’m going to suggest is that if you decide to D you commit to it.
What I’m going to suggest is that if you decide to R you commit to it.
That commitment – irrespective of decision – needs to be based on two things and two things only:
What YOU WANT
What YOU CAN GET
What the church-ladies, the pastor, posters here, the kids, her family, the man that sells newspapers or whatever wants has NO VALUE and NO WEIGHT.
They aren’t in your marriage. It’s YOUR marriage. At the end of the day when you sit and reflect on your life then the only factor that matters is that YOU are content and happy with what YOU did with your time. Not a shallow happiness like you might feel after watching Everybody Loves Raymond, but the happiness of knowing you did the best you could in your life.
It’s ONLY what you want. That is the ONLY factor.
Controlled IMMENSELY by what you can get.
If your wife is willing to completely cut off the AP, all enablers, be truthful, accept her total blame… you have a shot. You can reconcile and it’s something you can get.
But there is immense truth in what is shared on this site. It will only happen if your wife can and will accept ALL the blame for the affair. I don’t agree with the persuasive salesman and therefore she couldn’t avoid it crap. Your wife has to raise her hand and in front of herself and you admit that SHE decided to allow an affair to happen. That might not be necessary to START R, but definitely within the first six months.
AH – I’m not too optimistic for you. What is apparent is that you and WW have established a really strange form of interaction. Your communications are way off. There might be a lot of verbal noise, but it sounds like there isn’t much listening and a lot of confrontation. With a marriage as old as yours then changing that interaction will be hard. If you start to R then things will be all nice and fine and warm and cuddly until you both start using the old interaction methods.
IF you want to reconcile then you need to do immense work on the communications. Generally we don’t recommend MC early on in reconciliation, but I think that for YOU and YOUR situation you both need to see an MC with the emphasis on changing your interactions and learning new communications skills.
And AH – The marriage is her and you. Not the pastor, the friends from church and all that group. It’s not Jesus and Mary or the Big G. It’s you and your wife. I am a Christian and try to live by the principles Jesus taught us. I think that the BIG question we will be asked eventually is if we lived our lives to the fullest. Once again: a productive good fullest rather than a shallow fullest. I think remaining bound in a loveless marriage with no mutual respect simply to make some other people happy is not what was intended for us – not matter what the Lords self-proclaimed representatives here on Earth claim.
Just like you can try to reconcile if you want to do so you should feel equally free to decide to divorce if reconciliation isn’t working.