Sorry you're in this nightmare but glad you found SI.
As others have said, your wife isn't remorseful, she just wants you to shut up, quit asking questions, and let's just put all of this behind us.
Not just no but HELL NO!!
Listen, all of the questions that swirling around in your head are normal and right on the mark.
We certainly understand (and can appreciate) wanting to reconcile, but until you get the truth from your wife (not just some of the questions you have but ALL of them) that tug of war going on in your brain is just going to get worse over time.
I'm sure you can understand the logic of how can you forgive something (or someone) when you don't really know what you're exactly forgiving. Right?
Think about this. Your wife says "you weren't making her happy"?
So how did she deal with that?
By having a physical/emotional affair with another man?
Now she's not "happy" that her husband won't just shut the hell up and quit talking about HER affair and asking questions again about HER affair?
She's NOT your mommy and she does NOT get to put you in time out nor does she get to dictate how you want to react to this clusterfuck that SHE created.
Moving forward, your wife is sad or depressed, how's she going to deal with that? Have an affair?
She's angry? Have an affair?
She's anxious? Have an affair?
Your wife isn't just lying but she's a LIAR. Understand the difference? Someone can tell a lie but that doesn't necessarily make them a liar.
However when they continually lie to you, even after being busted, thus is about character (who and what they are) and unfortunately your wife is a liar and nothing she says should be believed.
Reconciliation is EXTREMELY hard to accomplish. Not saying it can be done, however it takes a LONG time and in order for it to even be considered as an option from the betrayed spouse (BS) both parties have to be all in.
Even if both parties say they're all in at that point nothing is guaranteed....it's just an attempt.
The lying cheating spouse has to get to the point that it's about remorse and NOT regret. Remorse is about the person you hurt and EVERYTHING moving forward is about helping the betrayed spouse heal and to show (over time) that you could eventually be a safe partner.
Your wife STABBED you in the heart, and you're laying there bleeding, and now what is she going to do about it? Tell you to shut up and lay there and quit asking for help as you slowly bleed out?
Your marriage is DEAD!!
Your wife KILLED it!!
Where do you go from here?
At the very least she should be willing to talk about it and answer your questions night and day 24/7 seven days a week if that's what you need right now.
If she's not willing to do this (and it sounds like she's not) you have nothing to work with.
Your wife BLEW up her marriage and her family because you weren't making her "happy".
Your wife sounds like a four year old.
I say this all the time here on SI. You want your wife to be honest with you, correct?
What's even more important is you being honest with yourself.
You can't change what you're afraid to confront.
The last you would want is to be dealing with this 5, 10, 15, 20 yrs from now, because you were too AFRAID to confront this head on.
Trust, respect, truth and honesty are the foundation of any relationship. Your wife has shown you flat out that you're not going to get this from her and now the question you need to ask yourself is how much do you truly VALUE these attributes and more importantly how much do you VALUE yourself??
Would you even consider marrying your wife way back if you knew she couldn't give you any of this (trust, respect, truth and honesty) and how about throwing in loyalty as well.
Would you think so little of yourself to marry someone that couldn't give you any of this?
Your wife is going to continue to lie to you.
Is this a deal breaker in your mind? Not just the affair but her still lying to you?
Please do NOT tell your wife about SI. This needs to be your safe place.
You need to do what you feel in your heart you need to do. If it were me, I would tell your wife she needs to write out a time-line detailing how this started, where they met, what they did, the lies she told, who else knew about it, and anything else she can think of.
Then I would schedule a polygraph and make sure you actually follow through having her take it even if she starts trickle truthing and confesses things in the parking lot.
Refusal to take poly means divorce.
The poly will confirm details in the time-line.
Go see an attorney to see what a divorce would look like.
Have you told her parents and family? Your parents and family?
I know you just want this all to go away and again so sorry you're in this nightmare.
One way or another you'll get through this. Have the courage to confront this, a list of things you need from her to even consider offering her the gift of reconciliation (and that's what it is...a GIFT).
Is she showing you she's worthy of the gift or is she going to continue to show you that it's ALL ABOUT HER???
She stabbed you in the back.
You're bleeding out.
What is she going to do?
Run off?
Stab you again?
Tell you to quit screaming?
Choose wisely.