Go back and read your first post.
You stated your marriage was already in a bad place and your wife said, "she's ALWAYS been attracted to him".
They kissed at a nightclub in Vegas, and she told you "she felt terrible afterwards" and yet not even a week later they "started texting again and meeting at work to kiss".
Grown adults making plans to meet to kiss??
You truly believe this garbage??
I mean COME ON!!
She then lies to you about him not being at the trip to Texas. You flat out asked her to "not have any further emotional or physical affair until we're separated. Anything else might DESTROY ME COMPLETELY".
You then find out HE IS THERE IN DALLAS.
So she lied.
She than tells you "she was in a terrible spot in our marriage and isn't sure she wants to try to fix it. She's not sure she can get back to being happy with me and us. Keep in mind we've struggled for a long time. We almost got separated in July".
"Turns out they met in Dallas for coffee and talked".
"He wants to be with her".
"He's in love with her".
You then find out he "loved the sunrise from her room".
You've stated "if" they had sex you're done.
You want proof despite already having enough evidence.
As others have pointed out (most recently Stevesn) if she won't "willingly" hand over her phone that tells you EVERYTHING you need to know.
I know this sucks but why would you believe anything your wife says to you given the countless times she's lied to you. Her lips move you know she's lying!
You say you want proof but your actions say otherwise.
You know why you don't want to force the issue? Your wife ALREADY had both feet out of the marriage with a man she's "always been attracted to" and you know she's been physical with him (sex NOT kissing) and if she's forced to take a polygraph to prove her innocence and to attempt to rebuild trust with you she knows she will fail because she's guilty as charged.
That's why she won't hand over her phone and more importantly why you won't flat out ask her for it.
That's why you won't demand her taking a polygraph because she'll just tell you "no" and there won't be any consequences of her declining to do so.
I know you want desperately to save your marriage and your family but my friend all of this is hanging by a thread.
If (and I mean a BIG IF) she truly thinks this was all a "mistake" and she really wanted to put the work in to rebuild trust and to potentially try to save your relationship she would be doing EVERYTHING possible to do so.
This piece of shit OM totally fucked over you and your family and as you stated "he's suffered no consequences" and he "needs a wake up call".
Your marriage was already on life support and her recent actions have killed it. It's DEAD!!
I know it hurts reading this.
That said there's still the opportunity to rebuild a new relationship/marriage but in order for that to happen she needs to put forth some effort to show you how badly she wants it.
She has done JACK SHIT so far which is very telling but what's even more telling is you not DEMANDING HER TO DO WHAT YOU NEED TO SEE THAT SHE'S BEING HONEST AND ULTIMATELY WHAT YOU'RE FORGIVING and she does this by handing over her phone and taking a polygraph.
2 X 4
Everyone is telling you to "wake up" because whether or not you want to believe this given what you're doing and what your wife isn't doing this is NOT going to play out the way you want to.
You say you want to save your marriage.
You say you want to do it for your kids.
Masters please for the love of God your fear is about to happen unless you start taking action.
Draw a damn line in the sand and say to your wife:
"I want this to work but if the roles were reversed would you have any trust in me"?
"You want me to believe you and to have a relationship that works we NEED to have trust".
"However I'm not the one who's lied countless times. I'm not the one who's claiming to just kiss another man".
"If you want us to have any chance at all to try and save this marriage you'll hand over your phone to me right now with NO HESITATION and you'll also take a polygraph".
"If you can't do this we're done because you may not value and respect me but I sure in the hell do".
"So please hand over your phone".
If she does it's a start.
If she doesn't she's gone Masters and there's nothing to save here. From your perspective there's something to save but her unwillingness to do this basically is telling you to FUCK OFF and she'll do whatever she wants and on her terms and if you don't like it deal with it.
Does this sound like a step to rebuild a new relationship/marriage?
Sound like something you're willing to accept?
You have an opportunity here.
You have to draw a hard line in the sand and be willing to have strong consequences if she steps over it.
Edit (sp)
[This message edited by Booyah at 5:14 PM, December 3rd (Tuesday)]