Alright, so I've read all the replies, and I gotta say, I feel like I was being steered towards an answer or being used to try to prove a point, and I didn't like it. Now I'm at my computer, and I'm not typing on a tiny goddamn phone screen, so I'll be able to formulate my thoughts better.
No, i wouldn't be completely thrilled about my 20 year old daughter dating a 50 year old man. He's older than me, even in the 4 years it would take for my oldest daughter to turn 20; I'd only be 39. Having a son in law older than me would just be weird.
I would be concerned that she would end up stuck caring for him in his older years, if their relationship lasted that long. Women are already defaulted and shoehorned into the caretaker role, and if they had kids together, then she would be caring for an aging husband as well as their children.
Yes, she would be more likely to be financially taken care of, but older men (specifically the aging Gen X and the younger Boomers) tend to have a disconnect emotionally and ideologically from the Millennial generation (mine) and the Gen Z (hers). I would worry about the conflicts between values.
HOWEVER.
If she is happy and the relationship is consentual and they are both faithful and content, then who the hell am I to object? I would be happier that she was happy than I would be worried about the difficulties. As a father, I will ALWAYS worry about the wellbeing of my girls, no matter the circumstances.
Me disapproving of her choice in partner over something like age or an attraction I don't understand would be like me disapproving of homosexual relationships because I'm not attracted to men, or men who like heavier women (BBWs) because I am not attracted to heavy women. Not my place to judge. I don't get it, I don't get the appeal, but it's still not my place.
I, personally, get along better with women who are just ever so slightly older than me; the youngest of the Gen X. I am an older Millennial (Jan '85), but I share a lot of GenX values and ethics that i don't see in the younger Millennials.
Yeah, a 25 year old hottie with perky hardware and a submissive/pliable mindset sounds really fun, but yaknow what? I'm setting up my first date as a single adult with a woman five years my senior. She has four kids and owns her own legal services business. She's been divorced for 8 years. She knows what she wants in life, she is confident in her needs and intelligent in her communication, she has her own house and income and she is her own woman.
I like that. It's worth more to me than a big chest, skinny waist, and giggly brain. She's taller than my physical ideal, a little heavier, and slightly more plain, but her personality is super cute nonetheless and she -knows who she is-.
I have, in my early 20s, been attracted to women in their 40s and 50s. Were they as OMG super-hot bangin' as some of the 20-25 year olds that were my peers? No, they weren't.
Well, some of them were, not gonna lie...
Again, they seemed powerful, driven, and confident, and I found that appealing. They knew what they wanted, and when they looked at me and sized me up, I could feel them regarding me, and I was flattered. Most of the women in my age group were hesitant or dismissive, like "he's not a backstreet boy/N*Synch clone, he's not a frosted tip boyband member, I can do better." I am heavyset and muscular, with broad features that are seldom seen as attractive in a conventional sense. i am by no means ugly, but I am plain. I have plenty of other skills to make me attractive or interesting, but at first glance, I'm nothing special.
These older women, these cougars, seemed to look past that. I've been told that my strong arms and shoulders are attractive, and always by older women. They listen to me and give me a chance to show my other skills and knowledges, and they appreciate them, rather than brushing them aside because I'm not wearing designer clothes.
Now, I've never gone after any of those women; I was married, after all, and I'm not a cheating piece of shit. But the age difference, just in and of itself, doesn't freak me out. It's the ramifications therein. If I had gotten with an older woman, having kids would have been harder to do, as well as harder on her body and with a higher chance of Down's Syndrome, IIRC.
But I'm done having kids now, and an older woman who has her shit figured out, well, that sounds nice. So does a 23 year old 115lb supermodel with thighs that could crush a watermelon and abs I could do laundry on, but one must be realistic.
[This message edited by Incarnate at 12:35 AM, February 4th (Tuesday)]