I think there is general consensus here how you should proceed. When you don’t get a lot of conflicting advice you should probably consider it to be good, which I see you are doing.
The one thing I’d add to it all is that at this point you need to tell her you are not interested in being a partner to the person she is right now.
If you find my advice on lots of threads here, you’ll see me say this often. “Betrayed spouses somehow mistakenly think that if their Wayward Partner simply ends the affair and goes no contact with their Affair Partner then things can just go back to the way they were. That what happened the last month or six or year or years somehow is magically wiped away.”
But the exact opposite is true. The old marriage not only can’t just restart as it was before. No. It’s dead. Hold a funeral. The fibers of that relationship, what held it together, have been destroyed forever by the cheating partner. It will never be the same.
And having that cheater simply say, it’s over, I’m sorry, I’ll work to change (which I haven’t even heard your WW say yet) doesn’t mean reconciliation even starts at that point.
NO! It is not until the cheater actually does the work to change, can convey empathy and remorse, true remorse as in feeling the pain more than their emotionally injured partner, digs deep in therapy to understand why they did what they did, and takes every step possible to be safe as a spouse, that rebuilding can EVEN START. That point doesn’t come for months or possibly even years.
RECONCILIATION IS NOT STARTED OR PROMISED UNTIL YHE CHEATER CAN MAKE THOSE THINGS HAPPEN. As i said, It takes months. It takes years. And when they finally become that person, then the Betrayed Partner can decide if they are interested in trying to rebuild a new marriage.
My friend, from what you have conveyed about your wife’s attitude and approach, you are no where near that point. You’re no closer than you were at DDay 5 months ago.
She still has a place in her heart for him. She hasn’t lost that. She has only artificially made a play at trying to placate you. She isn’t doing any real work. It’s all just words and not very good ones at that.
So in the spirit of what everyone here has told you, I’ll offer this sample approach and words. If it were me, I’d tell her something very simple and direct and then move on with my life. Don’t wait around. If she’s gonna do the work to change, she has to drive it, not you.
If you are truly going to find a path out of this, you have to State honestly and clearly what you need and want. You need to be completely honest to the most dishonest person in your life. Ironic, huh?
Here’s an example of what I’d say.
“You are my wife and i have always loved you. But i will not and can not share you emotionally and physically with another man. The last 6 months have shown me i am no better than second best in your heart. And I’m not sure i am that far up the ladder.
I need a partner who sees me as their one and only and discards anyone in their life that threatens that place. That’s how i have always viewed you. I would always eliminate from my life anyone that would make you uncomfortable in any way.
But your actions have made it quite clear that this other person is and will always be the most important person to you.
So i am letting you go. I don’t need a wife who only stays out of some sense of duty. I in no way want a life with someone who spends their days, Hours, even minutes pining away for someone else. That is not the formula for a happy life. I DO NOT WANT THAT.
So i will be filing for divorce this week. No more playing around with mediation. You can go be with him, or not, i no longer care. BUT I AM MOVING ON.
Even if you somehow were able to wipe him out of our lives forever, i will still divorce you. What you have done has destroyed our marriage. It no longer exists. So if you have an idea to make some grand statement, for the 4th time, save it, I no longer need the disappointment of false hope you give me each time. I have learned my lesson. Fool me 5 times, shame on me.
So expect to be served papers this week. If you truly want to do something for me, give me this divorce. Life with you, as it is now, is misery to me. My goal is to do this as amicably as possible.
If in the future you can see him as i do, as a miserable human who preys on others' lives and choose to wipe him out of your life for good, perhaps we can discuss what that means to us as more than parents of our kids. If I’m in a place in life where that’s of interest to me, then we can talk.
But I’m not holding my breath. It would take years of hard work for you to ever become someone i would consider safe enough to let in my heart again. I don’t see any way right now that you have it in you to do that work. You’re looking for something i obviously can’t provide you. I wish you luck in finding it. “
That’s it. Then stop talking relationship with her. It’s way too early for that anyway. She Stuck a knife in the center of your heart and while you are bleeding out she’s telling you she’s giving you one last chance to be a good husband and win her love. Screw that.
Time to focus on you and for right now, a life without her. I hope you can bring yourself to do that.
And stop playing around w mediation. Just go on and file. Yes probably more expensive but worth EVERY PENNY. Perhaps filing will get her into mediation.
Lastly you DO NOT HAVE TO WAIT to have this discussion. You are a good guy, but that is your biggest weakness right now. Tell her what you two are doing is not working. Her actions have made it impossible for you to just go back to loving her while she continues to pine away and most likely communicate behind your back for the 4th time. You have the right to say what you need and move on until you get it.
So do that. Tell her and move on. If she chases you then great, it’ll be the first true time she does. Start believing you are the prize you truly are, and if not for her, then for your next great love. Believe in yourself. As for her, she’s giving you nothing to believe in.
I hope you will consider what we are all saying to you and truly take action. You have one life. Demand what you need to enjoy living it.
Take care.
[This message edited by Stevesn at 12:55 PM, October 14th (Wednesday)]