Be careful of posts that put forth statements as facts.
I have been around this site for a long time and maybe the only "constant" in human interactions, behavior, actions, and reactions is that there is no constant. At best there are general rules, indicators and maybe even some stats that can be turned into odds.
Like your WW emotional affair. IMHO it already has some sexual context if they are sharing content that has the goal of creating arousal or sexual gratification or sexual reaction. This does not automatically mean that they will inevitably hook up for "real" sex, but our experience EA’s that have already crossed some sexual line probably develop into full physical affairs in 8/10 instances. If there are no serious geographical limitations, then maybe even 9/10.
9/10 isn’t the same as inevitable. There is still a 1/10 chance we are wrong. However, the odds are there, and we would be foolish to ignore them. Best way to deal with odds is to try to discern a pattern and then do something other than most do. After all – what most do is what creates the pattern.
I think the main reasons an EA develops into a full PA are a) the BS doesn’t know about it, so the EA has time to develop and progress along its path and b) the EA gets its time. Of the two I think time is the pan important factor.
Well… You have two factors that can allow you to beat the pattern. To tilt the odds in your favor. You know of the affair, and you can limit the time the affair gets.
Keep in mind you can’t guarantee it will end. Once again stats and trends… In about 5/10 instances affairs end once both WS and BS are aware what’s going on. So, if you were to confront your wife the odds are half that an already ongoing affair ends.
There are other things you can do to improve your odds. Rule-of-thumb is that men in affairs end the affair if their marriage is threatened. If you were to tell his wife about the affair the chances are probably 9/10, he will unceremoniously dump her. Suddenly, the odds of the affair ending go from 5/10 to 9/10.
Maybe your WW carries on the affair despite your knowledge. Maybe OM isn’t married, or has an open relationship, or his wife sticks her head in the sand. Whatever. Therefore, I started by stating there are no constants. But these are the odds and massaging them to your favor won’t hurt. Of course, none of this might pan out that way. These are my observations, and they might be spot-on, way off or factually wrong. But I wouldn’t be posting them if I didn’t think they were correct… correctish…
When to confront?
Now.
Like today.
I don’t think infidelity has any impact on divorce in any of the Canadian states/provinces so there isn’t really any need for you to document proof or whatever. It’s not as if your friend will forbid you from filing because you don’t have glossy pics or DNA evidence of an affair. If you want to file (or if you feel forced to file) you just file.
Any benefit of waiting longer will be wasted by the odds of the affair progressing.
How do you confront?
This is where I think most get it wrong.
You confront with knowledge. You KNOW she’s having an affair. Because you know you don’t have to prove it to her. It’s not a court of law where she’s innocent until proven guilty – you KNOW, and you are basically only announcing the sentence.
She doesn’t need to know how you know. In fact, you are allowed to lie about your proof. You could say you got a call, a friend told you or whatever. But the key is that you simply state YOU KNOW. The confrontation is not about her defending herself – it’s about letting her know YOU know and that you won’t accept her affair.
Another mistake I think we often do is impose draconian measures on the WS. It then becomes a battle of you against her and her happiness.
Look – I KNOW you want to reconcile but IMHO R or D isn’t the goal right now. The goal right now is to get out of infidelity. Those two options are IMHO the only two good options available. Some chose a third option and that’s settling for untreated or undealt with infidelity. They are content that the spouse might not be actively cheating now, but the underlying issues and the pain and damage caused is never dealt with.
Hang around this site and you will regularly see the post from some spouse that has tried to adjust to the Big Pink Elephant in the marriage for a decade but still has serious issues. IMHO THAT is the absolute worst outcome: remaining married on some pretext that divorce isn’t possible, and the infidelity can’t be fully handle.
Can your marriage survive?
Yes – definitely. We have numerous examples here on SI, including the founders of this site and some key mods, staff, and contributors.
Can this end in divorce?
Yes – definitely. We have numerous examples here on SI, mods, staff, and contributors.
Key factor is that those that deal with the issues can once again become happy. Irrespective of R or D it takes time and effort.
So… you confront with the intent of getting out of infidelity.
Plus, you put the onus of the next step towards saving the marriage on her.
I have a semi-standard speech that many have adapted to their use. It goes something like this:
"Wife. I always envisioned us together forever. I love you and am willing to do a lot to save this marriage. However. I know about OM (use his name), and I know you are having an affair with OM.
[No – don’t deny it – I KNOW. How I know isn’t relevant – I have more than enough proof and more than one source, so I am 100% convinced. I KNOW!]
I do not share my wife. Not anymore than I want to keep you prisoner in a marriage you clearly don’t want.
You can date him, be open about the relationship, spend nights and time with him, talk about him to your family and friends… whatever. There is no need for you to keep this a secret. He must mean a lot to you since you are so freely risking our marriage for him, and I won’t stand in the path of your happiness. The only concession I ask you to respect is that he does not come into my house. I believe I deserve that show of respect.
You are totally free to be with OM but not as my wife.
I am starting the process of ending our marriage. It’s two-faced. There is the emotional aspect that I must deal with and there is the practical legal aspect. I will eventually place that aspect into the hands of an attorney and will stick to the laws and regulations in our province. They are relatively fair, and we can do this in an amicable way.
If you want this marriage, you have a relatively short period now to let me know. It must be clear, unambiguous, and vocal. Only realize it’s your decision and your choice. I’m not forcing you to sacrifice anything, only refusing you to have everything. If you tell me, you want this marriage I will need some basic assurances, such as full transparency, total accountable NC, a detailed timeline, commitment to therapy and a plan for how you can be accountable, so I feel assured the affair is over.
I’m getting out of infidelity, with or without you. The further I go along this road without you the less likely am I to want you with me."
And then you just leave. Go make a sandwich or wax the car or whatever. There isn’t any need to discuss if it’s an affair or not, why she "had" to have the affair, how controlling you are…
No need for drama like flashing the Big D papers or printouts. The ball in in your court as to the next steps. The ball is in her court as to the next steps. Your power lies in that you can wait for some time before progressing to the next step.
What would the next step be?
Depends on her reaction.
No reaction and your next step are research divorce.
Next step is gathering the relevant documentation, appraisal of home, bank-accounts, credit-card accounts…
I know it’s not what you want, but surely it beats knowing your wife spent last evening with OM.
Next step is to shut her off when she starts talking about the vacation to Hawaii or dinner with her parents next month: Honey – you are committed to your infidelity, and I am detaching from our marriage. It’s not appropriate for us to behave as a happily married couple.
She tells you she wants the marriage:
A clear NC letters. Non-emotional and short. No last phone-call.
Ask her how she can assure you there is no contact. Refuse compromises (such as "just trust me").
A timeline.
A clear understanding that the only way forward is through truth.
Finally: One final suggestion:
She’s going to make all sorts of claims:
"This affair started because you didn’t talk to me" or "we grew apart" or "if you didn’t work so much…" or whatever.
Your standard stock reply is:
"I am sorry you feel that way. If we were working on our marriage, we might need to address that. Since you are committed to your affair there is really no need to deal with that issue" and then you move on."
IF she says she wants the marriage the answer changes a bit:
"I hear what you are saying, and we could address that in MC, but your decision to have an affair can never be blamed on the state of the marriage or what I did or did not do. It’s totally 100% your decision".