There have been quite a few times in this thread where you've taken a commentor to task for not remembering every detail of your situation, or disagreeing with you. Remember, we've been through this before and have different perspectives and experiences to help you through this.
OK. I am going to answer this one first and then I'l address Walloped's points one by one.
First, I try to answer most of the comments and recommendations. I do not understand why when I am given some pretty strident advice in a tone indicating I must be some kind of dummy and I have it all wrong that I am not allowed to push back a little and state my opinion of what was stated. And quite frankly, when you make a definitive and bold statement to someone on a very emotional issue you should have the details correct.
I do understand that everyone here has been through some form of this. That is what makes ALL of the opinions worth reading. I could just ignore what I disagree with but I am trying to be respectful in that if someone took the time to say something they deserve an answer. Just like I may not like some of the suggestions, some may not like my answers. That is OK too.
What really makes me understand that dynamic is I did read a lot of the Space Ghost thread, and the reverence for his firm stand and follow through. yet the thing went on for somewhere near 1000 posts and over i think 40 pages with some still telling him how stupid he was for not reconciling with his wife because of her tremendous remorse, which i did not see by the way until it was way too late.
The fist bit of advice I got here was to blow the affair up and stop it and that the quickest way to do that was to get to OM wife. I believe i did that in a pretty quick amount of time. And I have tried to explain to the best of my ability why i have not insisted that she resign tomorrow yet I continue to be told that she will do it with him again.
Next I was told to get a timeline. I got that. I got the sexual details ( not too much fun).
Next I have tried to ascertain if I think this was the only affair, and I have come to the conclusion that I cannot believe it without verification. MY WIFE CAME UP WITH THE POLYGRAPH idea before I got to it, but is being given no credit at all for that. i do not see that many WW on here volunteering for a test that can end their marriage with one wrong answer.
So, lets leave it that I may not be thrilled with some of the advice I am getting, and some may not be thrilled with my answers. my job here is not to apologize to anyone for not agreeing with them bashing me. It's called give and take, and in case you have not figured it out, I am not the type that takes without giving. Sorry, a flaw in my character.
Now let me answer Walloped's valid questions
a) No hesitation to do everything and anything I've asked
I asked her to not go out of town last week as scheduled. She did that immediately. I asked her to write a NC letter and she did it. i asked her to cut all communication and she did it. They do not need to communicate for any business reason as i explained since they are in the same job in different parts of the country reporting to different people. I asked her for a written timeline, and i got that. I can't think of what I asked for that I did not get.
b) Quit volunteering
No volunteering involved. I have not demanded she quit the job and have explained why a number of times.
c) She told the kids and her parents
My kids are not at home. They are away at school and will not be home until the end of school year. My son has Spring practice and my daughter is going on Spring Break ( and that is stressful in itself). There is absolutely no reason to call them on the phone and break this news to them, especially until I get more information. I do not want them told right now about anything. That is my right.
Her father is in very poor health. If I get divorced her parents obviously need to be told.
my brother knows and he agrees that no matter how he feels he has advised me AGAINST TELLING MY SISTERS or my parents unless I decide on divorce. So I have not asked her to do this and i would discourage it at this point right now if she said she was going to do it.
d) Tremendous amount of IC and workbooks, reading, etc. to understand her why and develop concrete, actionable steps to strengthen boundaries and work on her inner self-esteem and vulnerabilities
Valid point here. i have not gotten to deciding on IC or MC yet or both. Not ruling anything out. She is reading, started with "Not Just Friends". Obviously something went wrong on her boundaries, but her opportunity to fuck up was much greater than a SAHM. She spends a lot of time alone away from home and probably has been propositioned on the road or hit on an immense number of times more than most women. NOT AN EXCUSE, but a fact. if a woman goes out to GNO every Friday night surrounding herself with men trying to get in her pants, aren't her chances of making a terrible mistake increased. Does not change what she did. i do understand that.
e) Re-dedicated herself to me and our kids
She sat and listened to a pretty abusive phone call from OM wife, and has asked a lot of what she can do to help. Sorry, I am not telling her to quit her job tomorrow. I am discounting tears and emotional statements on her part. maybe I gave the impression she was sitting there cooly just like a stone and being very nonchalent. not the case.
f) Gives me space and asks me to communicate my needs so she can help me heal.
She left the house the first night when i asked her to. She has been sleeping in a spare bedroom. And other than a few instances she has not been overly clingy and oppressive. i want her around me to process how I feel. next week we both travel again for part of week.
g) No rugsweeping. Accepted the blame fully and with equivocation - owns her shit.
h) MC for us both to improve our communication skills.
i) Admitted and owned up to things I had no way of finding out
For brevity, Ill combine there. no question dodging, no refusing to answer everything I asked this past week end. As I stated, she did not have to tell me about the two dinners with guys she met at hotels she was staying at. I am leaning to MC rather than IC once I am sure I want to do either.
j) Passed polygraph test
That will happen. No argument there.
k) Tells me she loves me every day, that she is grateful I am giving her another chance to build a new life together, but recognizes that the decision is ultimately mine and is a consequence of her actions - and while she does not want a divorce, will give me one willingly if that's what I need to heal.
l) Recognizes that this was a significant trauma for me and offers assistance to help me deal with it, avoids triggers, etc.
I have not given a play by play but she is doing a lot of that. She knows I have seen an attorney so I do not believe she believes she is calling all the shot here. my biggest trigger will be next week when she heads to the airport a day before me. She also cancelled a girls trip she had planned. i did not insist on it before it was done.
m) Complete transparency. All electronic passwords. Lets me know where she is. Volunteers information.
I got it, and it is fine for insuring NC with OM. Does nothing for knowing if it was first time or if it happened again. That is why I feel I have no choice to poly. I have no intention to actually do it every time she spends a night out of town or away from me, but her willingness to do it was important to me.
Just wanted to have fun and
That and she liked the excitement and thrill of being wood was EXACTLY the explanation Mr. Space Ghost got, and there was a legion of folks imploring him to R even after he was long gone in Florida I believe.
The choice was cold and calculating. in my opinion it is for every woman because she has the last right of refusal unless she is raped.
There is not one WW who unless raped did not have the chance to stop it. My wife did not, Walloped's wife did not, and the wives of the countless on here who are trying to R did not.
Thats it for now. Sorry for the length of this, and sorry if some are taking my responses as an attack on them.